## How Well Do People Play a Quantum Prisoner’s Dilemma (2006)

Venue: | Quantum Information Processing |

Citations: | 6 - 5 self |

### BibTeX

@INPROCEEDINGS{Chen06howwell,

author = {Kay-yut Chen and Tad Hogg},

title = {How Well Do People Play a Quantum Prisoner’s Dilemma},

booktitle = {Quantum Information Processing},

year = {2006},

pages = {2006}

}

### OpenURL

### Abstract

Game theory suggests quantum information processing technologies could provide useful new economic mechanisms. For example, using shared entangled quantum states can alter incentives so as to reduce the free-rider problem inherent in economic contexts such as public goods provisioning. However, game theory assumes players understand fully the consequences of manipulating quantum states and are rational. Its predictions do not always describe human behavior accurately. To evaluate the potential practicality of quantum economic mechanisms, we experimentally tested how people play the quantum version of the prisoner’s dilemma game in a laboratory setting using a simulated version of the underlying quantum physics. Even without formal training in quantum mechanics, people nearly achieve the payoffs theory predicts, but do not use mixed-strategy Nash equilibria predicted by game theory. Moreover, this correspondence with game theory for the quantum game is closer than that of the classical game.

### Citations

1788 | The Complexity of Cooperation
- Axelrod
- 1997
(Show Context)
Citation Context ...ma involves the possibility of altruistic behaviors in which participants can either select actions that most benefit themselves or those that benefit the group as a whole but at some individual loss =-=[2]-=-. Game theory predicts defection independent of the number of players for the classical n-player prisoner’s dilemma (public goods game). However, the quantum version, when extended to multiple players... |

1070 |
The tragedy of the commons
- Hardin
- 1968
(Show Context)
Citation Context ... groups [8]. Specifically, for two players with equal preferences and endowments, the public goods problem reduces to the prisoner’s dilemma. The prisoner’s dilemma illustrates the free-rider problem =-=[17]-=- in the simplest context of a two-person game, in which each player has the choice to “cooperate” or “defect”. Payoffs for both players are higher when both of them choose to cooperate instead of both... |

559 |
Public Goods: A Survey of Experimental Research. Handbook of Experimental
- Ledyard
- 1995
(Show Context)
Citation Context ...e. Previous work in the classical prisoner’s dilemma has shown that even in randomly-matched games, people cooperated to some extent, usually explained by non-Nash behavioral effects such as altruism =-=[19]-=-. Thus we varied the payoffs to see if the quantum games shows similar behavior effects. As an additional comparison, we also ran a “repeated game” version of the experiment in which players were rand... |

252 |
The evolution of strategies in the iterated prisoner’s dilemma
- Axelrod
- 1987
(Show Context)
Citation Context ...rider problem cannot be solved with traditional means without either a third party to enforce agreements or a repeated game scenario in which participants can self-police (e.g., tit-for-tat behaviors =-=[3]-=-). While quantum information processing thus offers the possibility of creating new economics applications, many important questions are still unanswered. The most significant one is how people would,... |

190 |
Individual Decision Making
- Camerer
- 1995
(Show Context)
Citation Context ...s, i.e., the payoffs aren’t necessarily the same each time players make the same choices. These properties make it even more difficult for people to achieve the rational play predicted by game theory =-=[6]-=-. A second major question is how readily quantum games can be physically implemented, as they require the creation, transmission, storage and operation on entangled quantum states. While this issue is... |

113 |
Computer-Intensive Methods for Testing Hypotheses : An Introduction. Wiley-Interscience
- Noreen
- 1989
(Show Context)
Citation Context ... start of each period. We used two sets of payoffs, labelled as “Lo” and “Hi”, giving lower and higher incentives for cooperation, respectively, as indicated in Table 1. We used bootstrapping methods =-=[23]-=- for many statistical tests reported in this paper. Many comparisons, of cooperation rates and other measurements, were evaluated with permutation tests. Furthermore, all calculations were performed u... |

107 |
Optimal allocation of public goods: A solution to the ‘free-rider’ problem
- Groves, Ledyard
- 1977
(Show Context)
Citation Context ...ommunity so the taxing authority can determine the optimal amount of public goods to procure and hence set the corresponding taxation rate. A seminal classical solution is the GrovesLedyard mechanism =-=[16, 4]-=-, which can solicit truthful revelation of preferences in a incentive compatible manner. Another example is the provision point mechanism, which is popular amongst charities. In the provision point me... |

89 |
Provision of public goods: Fully implementing the core through private contributions
- Bagnoli, Lipman
- 1989
(Show Context)
Citation Context ...ommunity so the taxing authority can determine the optimal amount of public goods to procure and hence set the corresponding taxation rate. A seminal classical solution is the GrovesLedyard mechanism =-=[16, 4]-=-, which can solicit truthful revelation of preferences in a incentive compatible manner. Another example is the provision point mechanism, which is popular amongst charities. In the provision point me... |

77 |
QED: The strange theory of light and matter
- Feynman
- 2006
(Show Context)
Citation Context ...havior observed in the two prisoner’s dilemma games described by Table 1. 2.1 Playing the Quantum Game Quantum games [20] can be described in the standard mathematical framework for quantum mechanics =-=[14]-=-, which we briefly describe here in the context of the quantum version of the prisoner’s dilemma game. Players manipulate physical systems with two physical states (such as a photon with vertical or h... |

70 |
The Ultimatum Game
- Thaler
- 1988
(Show Context)
Citation Context ...even if the fraction of incorrect pairs is public knowledge provided participants do not know which particular pairs these are. Since people may not treat risks and probabilities in a rational manner =-=[25]-=-, it would be interesting to evaluate how such noise affects behavior. In particular, whether the game theory prediction that efficiency decreases smoothly with noise is consistent with human behavior... |

60 |
Quantum games and quantum strategies
- Eisert, Wilkens, et al.
- 1999
(Show Context)
Citation Context ...ts in quantum games. Extending classical games into the quantum realm broadens the range of strategies [20]. Examples of quantum games analyzed with game theory methods include the prisoner’s dilemma =-=[12, 13, 10, 11]-=- and the n-player minority game [5]. Of more direct relevance for economics are games involving correlated choices without communication [18, 22]. This raises the possibility of creating new economic ... |

48 |
The Dynamics of Social Dilemmas
- Glance, Huberman
- 1994
(Show Context)
Citation Context ...ficiency contrasts with the conventional observation that, in practice, free riding becomes more likely as group size increases due to the increased difficulty of monitoring behavior of group members =-=[15]-=-. Our experimental setup allows examining these assertions empirically. In the game we study [8], for n players, a source creates n(n−1)/2 entangled pairs of qubits and sends them to the players so th... |

38 | ed Strategy
- Witt, Meyer
- 1994
(Show Context)
Citation Context ...es of entangled quantum states over distances of tens of kilometers have led to increased interests in quantum games. Extending classical games into the quantum realm broadens the range of strategies =-=[20]-=-. Examples of quantum games analyzed with game theory methods include the prisoner’s dilemma [12, 13, 10, 11] and the n-player minority game [5]. Of more direct relevance for economics are games invol... |

21 |
Quantum Games
- Eisert, Wilkens
(Show Context)
Citation Context ...ts in quantum games. Extending classical games into the quantum realm broadens the range of strategies [20]. Examples of quantum games analyzed with game theory methods include the prisoner’s dilemma =-=[12, 13, 10, 11]-=- and the n-player minority game [5]. Of more direct relevance for economics are games involving correlated choices without communication [18, 22]. This raises the possibility of creating new economic ... |

21 | Correlated Equilibria of Classical strategies with Quantum Signals
- P
- 2005
(Show Context)
Citation Context ... theory methods include the prisoner’s dilemma [12, 13, 10, 11] and the n-player minority game [5]. Of more direct relevance for economics are games involving correlated choices without communication =-=[18, 22]-=-. This raises the possibility of creating new economic mechanisms using quantum information processing technologies. A quantum mechanism to produce public goods is one such example [8, 27]. Provisioni... |

16 |
Testing Game-Theoretic Models of Free Riding: New Evidence
- Palfrey, Rosenthal
- 1991
(Show Context)
Citation Context ... in quantum mechanics? Even for conventional games, the predictions of game theory do not always match human behavior because the theory often assumes unrealistic levels of rationality of its players =-=[24, 7]-=-. Furthermore, people are known not to play mixed strategies even when game theory indicates rational players would do so. Proposed quantum games often have no single-strategy Nash equilibrium and mul... |

14 |
Multi-Player Quantum Games
- Benjamin, Hayden
- 2001
(Show Context)
Citation Context ...nto the quantum realm broadens the range of strategies [20]. Examples of quantum games analyzed with game theory methods include the prisoner’s dilemma [12, 13, 10, 11] and the n-player minority game =-=[5]-=-. Of more direct relevance for economics are games involving correlated choices without communication [18, 22]. This raises the possibility of creating new economic mechanisms using quantum informatio... |

12 |
Classical rules in quantum games
- Enk, Pike
(Show Context)
Citation Context ...perations on physical quantum states, players sent their choices of quantum operators to a computer server which then performed the operations on simulated quantum states. Simulation of quantum games =-=[26]-=- is suitable for laboratory studies which guarantee participants follow the rules of the game without need for the security properties of a physical implementation or developing the legal sanctions of... |

10 |
A Cognitive Hierarchy Model of One-Shot Games
- Camerer, Ho, et al.
(Show Context)
Citation Context ... in quantum mechanics? Even for conventional games, the predictions of game theory do not always match human behavior because the theory often assumes unrealistic levels of rationality of its players =-=[24, 7]-=-. Furthermore, people are known not to play mixed strategies even when game theory indicates rational players would do so. Proposed quantum games often have no single-strategy Nash equilibrium and mul... |

9 | A quantum treatment of public goods economics. Quantum Information Processing 1:449–469. arxiv.org preprint quantph/0301013
- Chen, Hogg, et al.
- 2002
(Show Context)
Citation Context ...munication [18, 22]. This raises the possibility of creating new economic mechanisms using quantum information processing technologies. A quantum mechanism to produce public goods is one such example =-=[8, 27]-=-. Provisioning of public goods is one of the most important economic contexts giving rise to the free-rider problem. The free-rider problem cannot be solved with traditional means without either a thi... |

7 | Quantum Solution of Coordination Problems
- Huberman, Hogg
- 1997
(Show Context)
Citation Context ... theory methods include the prisoner’s dilemma [12, 13, 10, 11] and the n-player minority game [5]. Of more direct relevance for economics are games involving correlated choices without communication =-=[18, 22]-=-. This raises the possibility of creating new economic mechanisms using quantum information processing technologies. A quantum mechanism to produce public goods is one such example [8, 27]. Provisioni... |

5 |
Quantum communication in games
- Meyer
- 2004
(Show Context)
Citation Context ...ng for future work more complicated comparisons with conventional economic approaches to free riding or allowing use of classically correlated rather than entangled quantum states to enhance the game =-=[21]-=-. Sec. 3 discusses the design of the experiment on human subjects playing this game. Sec. 4 describes resulting behaviors we observed and how they compare to game theory predictions. Sec. 6 concludes ... |

3 |
Reduced entanglement for quantum games
- Zhang, Hogg
(Show Context)
Citation Context ...munication [18, 22]. This raises the possibility of creating new economic mechanisms using quantum information processing technologies. A quantum mechanism to produce public goods is one such example =-=[8, 27]-=-. Provisioning of public goods is one of the most important economic contexts giving rise to the free-rider problem. The free-rider problem cannot be solved with traditional means without either a thi... |

2 | Computer games and experimental economics - Chen, Wu - 2003 |