The Moral Behavior of Ethicists and the Power of Reason (2013)
BibTeX
@MISC{Rust13themoral,
author = {Joshua Rust and Eric Schwitzgebel},
title = {The Moral Behavior of Ethicists and the Power of Reason},
year = {2013}
}
Share
 |
 |
 |
 |
||
OpenURL
Abstract
Professional ethicists behave no morally better, on average, than do other professors. At least that’s what we have found in a series of empirical studies that we will summarize below. Our results create a prima facie challenge for a certain picture of the relationship between intellectual reasoning and moral behavior – a picture on which explicit, intellectual cognition has substantial power to change the moral opinions of the reasoner and thereby to change the reasoner’s moral behavior. Call this picture the Power of Reason view. One alternative view has been prominently defended by Jonathan Haidt. We might call it the Weakness of Reason view, or more colorfully the Rational Tail view, after the headline metaphor of Haidt’s seminal 2001 article, “The emotional dog and its rational tail ” (in Haidt’s later 2012 book, the emotional dog becomes an “intuitive dog”). According to the Rational Tail view (which comes in different degrees of strength), emotion or intuition drives moral opinion and moral behavior, and explicit forms of intellectual cognition function mainly post-hoc, to justify and socially communicate conclusions that flow from emotion or intuition. Haidt argues that our empirical results favor his view (2012, p. 89). After all, if intellectual styles of moral reasoning don’t detectably improve the behavior even of professional ethicists who build their careers on expertise in such reasoning,
Keyphrases
moral behavior reason view rational tail view professional ethicist emotional dog prima facie challenge intellectual cognition function communicate conclusion certain picture different degree intellectual reasoning intuition drive moral opinion reasoner moral behavior rational tail empirical study intuitive dog moral opinion jonathan haidt intellectual cognition substantial power alternative view intellectual style empirical result explicit form headline metaphor
