Abstract

In this paper we take a rather unusual, non-technical approach and investigate object-oriented programming and the prototype-based programming field from a purely philosophical viewpoint. Some historical facts and observations pertaining to objects and prototypes are presented, and conclusions based on those observations are derived.

Citations

520	Self: the power of simplicity - Ungar, Smith - 1987
504	Designing Reusable Classes - Johnson, Foote - 1988
481	No silver bullet: Essence and accidents of software engineering - Brooks - 1987
409	Philosophical investigations - Wittgenstein - 1953
388	W.: Mixin-based inheritance - Bracha, Cook - 1990
327	Refactoring Object-Oriented Frameworks - Opdyke - 1992
322	Using Prototypical Objects to Implement Shared Behavior in Object Oriented Systems - Lieberman
301	Family resemblances: studies in the internal structure of categories - Rosch, Mervis - 1975
137	A Denotational Semantics of Inheritance - Cook - 1989
84	Creating Abstract Superclasses by Refactoring - Opdyke, Johnson - 1993
64	Interfaces and Specifications for the Smalltalk-80 Collection Classes - Cook - 1992
60	Classes versus prototypes in object-oriented languages - Borning - 1986
48	A shared view of sharing: the treaty of Orlando - Stein, Lieberman, et al. - 1988
45	Object-Preserving Class Transformations - Bergstein - 1991
43	An Incremental Class Reorganization Approach - Casais - 1992
40	J.R.: An exemplar based smalltalk - LaLonde, Thomas, et al. - 1986
33	Prototype-based languages: From a new taxonomy to constructive proposals and their validation - Dony, Malenfant, et al. - 1992
29	A Critical View of Inheritance and Reusability in ObjectOriented Programming - Taivalsaari - 1993
25	Name Collision in Multiple Classification Hierarchies - Knudsen - 1988
18	Philosophical Papers - Austin - 1961
12	Kevo -- a prototype-based object-oriented language based on concatenation and module operartions - Taivalsaari - 1992
11	Object-Oriented Programming with Prototypes - Blaschek - 1994
8	What IS-A is and isn’t - Brachman - 1983
7	The Newton Application Architecture - Smith - 1994
3	Type-safe OOP with prototypes: the concepts of Omega - Blaschek - 1991
1	The complete works of Aristotle volume 1 (the revised Oxford translation - Barnes, J - 1984
1	The republic. Kustannusosakeyhti�� Otava - Plato - 1981
1	The mathematics of inheritance systems. Research notes in artificial intelligence - Touretzky, S - 1986
1	enough software. Application Development Strategies vol 8, nr 1 - Yourdon, Good - 1996