## Front Propagation in the Pearling Instability of Tubular Vesicles (1996)

Venue: | J. Phys. II (France |

Citations: | 5 - 0 self |

### BibTeX

@ARTICLE{Goldstein96frontpropagation,

author = {Raymond E. Goldstein and Joseph Henry and Philip Nelson and Thomas Powers and Udo Seifert},

title = {Front Propagation in the Pearling Instability of Tubular Vesicles},

journal = {J. Phys. II (France},

year = {1996},

volume = {6},

pages = {767--796}

}

### OpenURL

### Abstract

this paper we will present a more detailed analysis addressing these and many other points. After reviewing the experimental facts in Sect. 2, we will build up a physical picture of the pearling system in Sect. 3. In particular we will show that assumption (b) above is a good approximation during the time regime of the experiment, so that pearling is essentially the invasion of a saturating front into a uniform linearly-unstable state. To get to the point as quickly as possible we will construct in Sect. 4 a very simple form of the three-fluid model which captures most of the essential physics without lengthy formulas. We then analyze the front propagation in Sect 5 using the marginal stability criterion (or

### Citations

1426 |
Classical Electrodynamics
- Jackson
- 1999
(Show Context)
Citation Context ...m −3 . Taking the dielectric contrast between water and lipid at this frequency to be of order δǫ = 0.23 [34], we see that when a lipid molecule falls into the trap displacing water we gain an energy =-=[35]-=- ∼ Eδǫ · a 0 D, where a 0 is the area of the molecule’s head and D is its total length. Taking 2D ∼ 40˚A, we get that each unit of bilayer area sucked into the trap yields an energy gain of Σ ∼ 2 · 10... |

368 |
Intermolecular and Surface Forces
- Israelachvili
- 1991
(Show Context)
Citation Context ... over a spot of diameter 0.3µm, corresponds to an energy density in vacuum E of 2.3 ·10 4 erg cm −3 . Taking the dielectric contrast between water and lipid at this frequency to be of order δǫ = 0.23 =-=[34]-=-, we see that when a lipid molecule falls into the trap displacing water we gain an energy [35] ∼ Eδǫ · a 0 D, where a 0 is the area of the molecule’s head and D is its total length. Taking 2D ∼ 40˚A,... |

240 |
Fluid Mechanics (Pergamon
- L, Lifshitz
- 1959
(Show Context)
Citation Context ...I0I1 ] 3I0K0 /k − K1I1 /k + k(I2 1K2 0 − I2 0K2 1 ) . (D.9) In eqn. (D.9) all Bessel functions are to be evaluated at k. 16 We have used Tij = −pδ ij + η(∂ i v j + ∂ j v i ) for incompressible fluids =-=[50]-=-. 36Appendix E. Membrane Elasticity Here we briefly derive eqn. (6.5). Following previous authors (e.g. [5][6]) we visualize each monolayer as a fluid of compressible cylinders, each of length D. One... |

174 |
Mechanisms of intracellular protein transport. Nature 372
- Rothman
- 1994
(Show Context)
Citation Context ...nced [1][2]. Most interesting biophysical phenomena, however, are not in equilibrium, and the study of the dynamics of vesicle shapes is somewhat less developed. For example, budding and vesiculation =-=[3]-=- and instabilities crucial for understanding adhesion [4], are all inherently dynamical processes. To gain a physical understanding of non-equilibrium membrane dynamics we must begin with experiments ... |

62 | Statique expérimentale et théorique des liquides soumis aux seules forces moléculaires. Paris: Gauthier-Villars, Trubner et. Cie - Plateau |

55 |
On the instability of jets
- Rayleigh
(Show Context)
Citation Context ...esting dynamical system. The pearling phenomenon bears a superficial resemblance to the instability of a cylindrical column of water in air, studied in the classical works of Plateau and Rayleigh [14]=-=[15]-=-[16]. In this situation surface tension destabilizes the cylinder, since the same volume per unit length can be contained with less surface area as a string of spherical droplets. As in other pattern-... |

40 |
private communication
- Thomas
- 2000
(Show Context)
Citation Context ...essure or by pulling out a small inclusion in the membrane [7][9]. Such tethers sometimes contain pearls. Also lowertemperature experiments, where in-plane order is important, can give pearled shapes =-=[28]-=-. All of these experiments have in common that the formation of pearls is coterminous with the formation of the tethers themselves, and small-amplitude sinusoidal modulations are not seen. Finally, ex... |

33 |
Physical properties of surfactant bilayer membranes: thermal transitions, elasticity, rigidity, and colloidal
- Evans, Needham
- 1987
(Show Context)
Citation Context ...upport of this research. Appendix A. A Compendium of Constants Here we list the values of various physical constants for DMPC bilayers. We take: the bilayer bending stiffness to be κ = 0.6 · 10−12erg =-=[43]-=-, the bilayer thickness to be 2D = 40˚A [44], 32the distance from bilayer midplane to each monolayer neutral surface to be d ∼ D/3 = 12˚A [40][6], the bare bilayer compression modulus to be K 0 = 144... |

27 |
CRC Handbook of Lipid Bilayers
- Marsh
- 1990
(Show Context)
Citation Context ...ndium of Constants Here we list the values of various physical constants for DMPC bilayers. We take: the bilayer bending stiffness to be κ = 0.6 · 10−12erg [43], the bilayer thickness to be 2D = 40˚A =-=[44]-=-, 32the distance from bilayer midplane to each monolayer neutral surface to be d ∼ D/3 = 12˚A [40][6], the bare bilayer compression modulus to be K 0 = 144 ergcm −2 [43], the interlayer friction cons... |

23 |
Entropy-driven tension and bending elasticity in condensed-fluid membranes
- Evans, Rawicz
- 1990
(Show Context)
Citation Context ...ections can be significant. At modest values of tension, the membrane effectively becomes elastic, because significant area can hide in invisible short-scale wrinkles excited by thermal agitation [48]=-=[7]-=-. (The tiny value reported for the bare K −1 0 in [7] is attained only at extremely large values of applied tension, where these wrinkles have been extinguished.) Following Helfrich and Servuss, let u... |

23 |
On the instability of cylindrical thread of a viscous liquid surrounded by another viscous liquid
- Tomotika
- 1935
(Show Context)
Citation Context ...t a thread of liquid surrounded by air. Long ago Tomotika considered a two-fluid model, in which a column of one viscous fluid is initially immersed in another with a certain positive surface tension =-=[17]-=-. One could imagine that these two fluids correspond to the interior and exterior water, so that both viscosities are equal. Specializing Tomotika’s result to this case, one finds the fastest-growing ... |

17 |
A cascade of structure in a drop falling from a faucet, Science 265
- Shi, Brenner, et al.
- 1994
(Show Context)
Citation Context ...d to other fluid dynamics problems. One particularly relevant problem is the propagation of the ordinary Rayleigh instability along a column of fluid, as seen in recent experiments on droplet fission =-=[42]-=-. We are not aware of any naturally-occurring biological process to which the pearling instability literally applies. Our goal was rather to create a simple theory of membrane dynamics and test its ma... |

15 |
On the stability of a cylinder of viscous liquid under capillary force", Scienti c Papers, iii
- Rayleigh
- 1902
(Show Context)
Citation Context ...ng dynamical system. The pearling phenomenon bears a superficial resemblance to the instability of a cylindrical column of water in air, studied in the classical works of Plateau and Rayleigh [14][15]=-=[16]-=-. In this situation surface tension destabilizes the cylinder, since the same volume per unit length can be contained with less surface area as a string of spherical droplets. As in other pattern-form... |

14 |
Topology transitions and singularities in viscous flows
- Goldstein, Pesci, et al.
- 1993
(Show Context)
Citation Context ...ation between pressure gradients and velocity in (7.4) are features found as well in models introduced recently for interface motion leading to topology transitions and singularities in viscous flows =-=[41]-=-. In all of these systems, despite the simplicity of the physical ingredients, the equation of motion is highly nonlinear and of very high degree (sixth order in z-derivatives in the present case). Th... |

11 |
Instability and ‘pearling’ states produced in tubular membranes by competition of curvature tension
- Bar-Ziv, Moses
- 1994
(Show Context)
Citation Context ...upon a cylindrical structure modulated with pearls can emerge [11]. Recently Moses and Bar-Ziv have introduced a new class of experiments in which laser tweezers act directly on single lipid bilayers =-=[12]-=-. It is already perhaps surprising that there should be any action at all, since the optical absorption of a single bilayer is so small. As we will recall in Sect. 3 below, we argued in [13] that the ... |

10 | Propagating Pattern Selection - Dee, Langer - 1983 |

9 |
R.: Adhesion of vesicles
- Seifert, Lipowsky
- 1990
(Show Context)
Citation Context ...scribe from first principles, yet complicated enough to display lifelike behavior. The study of the equilibrium configurations of closed bags of lipid bilayers (“vesicles”) is by now well advanced [1]=-=[2]-=-. Most interesting biophysical phenomena, however, are not in equilibrium, and the study of the dynamics of vesicle shapes is somewhat less developed. For example, budding and vesiculation [3] and ins... |

9 |
Morphological changes in liposomes caused by polymerization of encapsulated actin and spontaneous formation of actin bundles
- Miyata, Hotani
- 1992
(Show Context)
Citation Context ...dry lipid [8], and by the incorporation of a small object which is subsequently pulled away with laser tweezers [9]. One can even create tension inside a vesicle by polymerizing a stiff rod inside it =-=[10]-=-, whereupon a cylindrical structure modulated with pearls can emerge [11]. Recently Moses and Bar-Ziv have introduced a new class of experiments in which laser tweezers act directly on single lipid bi... |

9 |
A.: Hidden dynamics in rapid changes of bilayer shape
- Evans, Yeung
- 1994
(Show Context)
Citation Context ...et a four-fluid model. The motivation for this is that dynamical friction between the two leaves of the bilayer has been shown to be quite significant for a related class of membrane problems [21][22]=-=[23]-=-, though as we will see the actual effect on our answers will be slight. Again using the MSC, we first find that the initial wavenumber is k0 = 0.80, which agrees with experiment somewhat better than ... |

9 |
Propagating pattern selection, Phys
- Dee, Langer
- 1983
(Show Context)
Citation Context ...formulas. We then analyze the front propagation in Sect 5 using the marginal stability criterion (or 2 Actually we quoted kmax = 0.65 due to an error which we will correct in eqn. 4.2 below. 3“MSC”) =-=[19]-=-[20] and show how it gives qualitatively correct results for vf and k when applied to our simple model. As we will recall, the MSC allows one to compute the front velocity using only the linearized dy... |

8 |
Frequency spectrum of the flicker phenomenon in erythrocytes
- Brochard, Lennon
- 1975
(Show Context)
Citation Context ...ure Π of the intermediate fluid, which in turn emerges from the appropriate hydrodynamic equations. The key early works on membrane dynamics used models of this type to study equilibrium fluctuations =-=[18]-=-. In the pearling experiment the laser takes the system far from equilibrium by suddenly imposing a boundary condition on Π. In other words, the laser trap is regarded as a lipid reservoir located at ... |

7 |
Local and nonlocal curvature elasticity in bilayer membranes by tether formation from lecithin vesicles, Biophys
- Waugh, Song, et al.
- 1992
(Show Context)
Citation Context ...t be quite so sure about density difference, however. The two monolayers are like a pair of polymer brushes in contact, and so the friction coefficient between the two layers can be (and is) enormous =-=[40]-=-[23]. Leaving ˆχ free, we then finally obtain the elastic energy ∫ F[H, ˆχ] = { κ dS 2 (2H)2 2 K0d + 2 (2H − 2H0 ) 2 + K0 (( ) d 2 2 2d 2 ˆχ + 2R0 2 R0 (H − H0 )ˆχ ) + Σ } . (6.9) To gain a physical f... |

6 |
Curvature instability in membranes
- Leibler
- 1986
(Show Context)
Citation Context ...n mixed surfactant systems have shown equilibrium peristaltic shapes [29]. This is presumably due to shape-composition coupling, which is known to lead to an instability towards an asymmetric bilayer =-=[30]-=-[31] and thence to the mechanism of [32]. 3. Physical Picture In Rayleigh’s problem, the tension was a material parameter characterizing the airwater interface, and hence trivially constant. In our ca... |

6 |
Undulations, steric interaction and cohesion of fluid membranes
- Helfrich, Servuss
- 1984
(Show Context)
Citation Context ...corrections can be significant. At modest values of tension, the membrane effectively becomes elastic, because significant area can hide in invisible short-scale wrinkles excited by thermal agitation =-=[48]-=-[7]. (The tiny value reported for the bare K −1 0 in [7] is attained only at extremely large values of applied tension, where these wrinkles have been extinguished.) Following Helfrich and Servuss, le... |

5 |
Molecular friction and epitactic coupling between monolayers in supported bilayers
- Merkel, Sackmann, et al.
- 1989
(Show Context)
Citation Context ...−2 [43], the interlayer friction constant b to be 10 8 ergsec cm −4 [21], the viscosity of water η to be 1 · 10 −2 ergsec cm −3 , and the 2d viscosity of the lipid layer to be µ = 10 −6 erg sec cm −2 =-=[45]-=-. In addition for concreteness we sometimes take: the typical tubule radius R 0 = 0.7µm(ref. [12], fig 1), the typical laser power 50mW [12], and the temperature to be k B T = 4.2 · 10 −14 erg . Thus ... |

5 |
Vortex front propagation in rotating CouetteTaylor
- Ahlers, Cannell
- 1983
(Show Context)
Citation Context ...he MSC”, and use them to fix the three real variables v ∗ , Re q ∗ , Im q ∗ . There is a large literature on experimental tests of pattern selection via the MSC. Important early studies include refs. =-=[39]-=-. We can also use (5.1)–(5.2) to determine the selected wavenumber q 0 of the stationary pattern behind the front. In the comoving frame of the front, the saturated pattern is continuously created at ... |

4 |
private communication
- Needham
(Show Context)
Citation Context ...shape transformations can be induced by adjusting temperature in closed vesicles [5][6]. Strings of beads can be induced by relieving tension using micropipettes [7], by sudden hydration of dry lipid =-=[8]-=-, and by the incorporation of a small object which is subsequently pulled away with laser tweezers [9]. One can even create tension inside a vesicle by polymerizing a stiff rod inside it [10], whereup... |

4 |
The conformation of membranes, Nature 349
- Lipowsky
- 1991
(Show Context)
Citation Context ... describe from first principles, yet complicated enough to display lifelike behavior. The study of the equilibrium configurations of closed bags of lipid bilayers (“vesicles”) is by now well advanced =-=[1]-=-[2]. Most interesting biophysical phenomena, however, are not in equilibrium, and the study of the dynamics of vesicle shapes is somewhat less developed. For example, budding and vesiculation [3] and ... |

3 | Interfacial instability at cell membranes - Gallez, Coakley - 1986 |

3 |
Dynamic coupling and nonlocal curvature elasticity in bilayer membranes, in: The Structure and Conformation of Amphiphilic Membranes
- Evans, Yeung, et al.
- 1991
(Show Context)
Citation Context ...rs, to get a four-fluid model. The motivation for this is that dynamical friction between the two leaves of the bilayer has been shown to be quite significant for a related class of membrane problems =-=[21]-=-[22][23], though as we will see the actual effect on our answers will be slight. Again using the MSC, we first find that the initial wavenumber is k0 = 0.80, which agrees with experiment somewhat bett... |

3 |
Theoretical explanation for myelin shapes of red blood cells. Blood Cells 3(3):713–720
- HJ, Helfrich
- 1977
(Show Context)
Citation Context ...uilibrium peristaltic shapes [29]. This is presumably due to shape-composition coupling, which is known to lead to an instability towards an asymmetric bilayer [30][31] and thence to the mechanism of =-=[32]-=-. 3. Physical Picture In Rayleigh’s problem, the tension was a material parameter characterizing the airwater interface, and hence trivially constant. In our case we argued in the Introduction that te... |

3 |
Local unbinding of pinched membranes
- Bar-Ziv, Menes, et al.
- 1995
(Show Context)
Citation Context ... meets all these conditions we will call the front unstable in its comoving frame. 11 In the present case the laser itself provides the initial disturbance; for another example see the photographs in =-=[38]-=-. 18Of course the assumed front solution itself corresponds at its leading edge to one particular linear solution with some q ∗ , and so v ∗ = Re ω ∗ /Re q ∗ (5.1) where ω ∗ = ω(q ∗ ). Let us now con... |

2 |
Dynamical theory of the pearling instability in cylindrical vesicles. Phys Rev Lett 74(17):3384–3387
- Nelson, Powers, et al.
- 1995
(Show Context)
Citation Context ...hat tension is instead a dynamical variable, and so its spread must be self-consistently determined along with the change of shape. Our main objective in this section is to justify the assumption [12]=-=[13]-=- that tension initially spreads so rapidly that it effectively becomes constant and uniform as soon as the laser is turned on3 . Thus the spread of tension is not what limits the speed of initial prop... |

2 |
Curvature-induced lateral phase separation in two-component vesicles,” Phys
- Seifert
- 1993
(Show Context)
Citation Context ...xed surfactant systems have shown equilibrium peristaltic shapes [29]. This is presumably due to shape-composition coupling, which is known to lead to an instability towards an asymmetric bilayer [30]=-=[31]-=- and thence to the mechanism of [32]. 3. Physical Picture In Rayleigh’s problem, the tension was a material parameter characterizing the airwater interface, and hence trivially constant. In our case w... |

2 |
Covariant hydrodynamics of fluid membranes
- Cai, Lubensky
- 1994
(Show Context)
Citation Context ...effective modulus. Following [48], the relative area extension as we change the dimensionless tension σ is δA/A ∼ k B T 8π 2 ∫ √ σ √ σ0 dk k 2 κk 4 15 Something similar happens with dynamic couplings =-=[47]-=-. 34In our case σ ∼ 20 (Appendix A.). The lower bound of the integral should be either the initial tension or unity, whichever is larger, to account for the cylindrical geometry; since we take the in... |

1 | The conformation of membranes," Nature 349 - Lipowsky - 1991 |

1 | Shape transformation of vesicles," Phys. Rev. A44 - Seifert, Berndl, et al. - 1991 |

1 | Budding transitions of fluidbilayer vesicles," Phys. Rev. E49 - Miao, Seifert, et al. - 1994 |

1 |
private communication; see also
- Pouligny
- 1994
(Show Context)
Citation Context ...ads can be induced by relieving tension using micropipettes [7], by sudden hydration of dry lipid [8], and by the incorporation of a small object which is subsequently pulled away with laser tweezers =-=[9]-=-. One can even create tension inside a vesicle by polymerizing a stiff rod inside it [10], whereupon a cylindrical structure modulated with pearls can emerge [11]. Recently Moses and Bar-Ziv have intr... |

1 |
private communication
- Fygenson
(Show Context)
Citation Context ...uently pulled away with laser tweezers [9]. One can even create tension inside a vesicle by polymerizing a stiff rod inside it [10], whereupon a cylindrical structure modulated with pearls can emerge =-=[11]-=-. Recently Moses and Bar-Ziv have introduced a new class of experiments in which laser tweezers act directly on single lipid bilayers [12]. It is already perhaps surprising that there should be any ac... |

1 | Sarloos, "Front propagation into unstable states," Phys. Rev. A37 - van - 1988 |

1 | Viscous modes of bilayer membranes - Seifert, Langer - 1993 |

1 |
Dynamics of Rayleigh-like instability induced by laser tweezers in tubular vesicles of self-assembled membranes
- Granek, Olami
- 1995
(Show Context)
Citation Context ...ns a glossary of symbols used for physical constants, and their values. Granek and Olami were the first to attempt a realistic treatment of pearling without the simplifying assumptions (a), (b) above =-=[24]-=-. While our physical picture and conclusions are different from theirs, we are indebted to them for emphasizing these issues. We are also grateful to Moses and Bar-Ziv, who first suggested to us that ... |

1 | private communication - Svetina |

1 |
Bending resistance and chemically induced moments in membrane bilayers," 14
- unknown authors
- 1974
(Show Context)
Citation Context ... our case there is no such asymmetry; as we will 5recall in Sect. 3.1 below, the fact that each leaf of the bilayer is initially in equilibrium with a common lipid reservoir then implies that c0 = 0 =-=[27]-=-. Evans and Rawicz, and recently Pouligny, have rapidly formed thin tethers coming from large vesicles, respectively by adjusting the internal pressure or by pulling out a small inclusion in the membr... |

1 |
A phase of liposomes with entangled tubular vesicles," Science 266
- Chiruvolu, Warriner, et al.
- 1994
(Show Context)
Citation Context ...inous with the formation of the tethers themselves, and small-amplitude sinusoidal modulations are not seen. Finally, experiments in mixed surfactant systems have shown equilibrium peristaltic shapes =-=[29]-=-. This is presumably due to shape-composition coupling, which is known to lead to an instability towards an asymmetric bilayer [30][31] and thence to the mechanism of [32]. 3. Physical Picture In Rayl... |

1 | Bending energy of vesicle membranes," Phys. Rev. A39 - Zhong-can, Helfrich - 1989 |

1 | Entropic expulsion in vesicles", preprint - Bar-Ziv, Frisch, et al. - 1995 |

1 |
Transbilayer and interbilayer phospholipid exchange in dimyristoylphosphatidylcholine/dimyristoylphosphatidylethanolamine large unilamellar vesicles," Biochemistry 30
- Wimley, Thompson
- 1991
(Show Context)
Citation Context ... Bruinsma for suggesting this estimate. 8of a second) in question6 , and transfer of lipid from one leaf to the other (“flipflop”) also remains too slow to be of interest, as in unstressed membranes =-=[37]-=-. Further support for our model of the origin of pearling by laser-induced tension comes from the observation that mechanical tension applied suddenly to a cylindrical vesicle (by dragging an end atta... |

1 |
Cours de math'ematiques g'en'erales
- Bouasse
- 1911
(Show Context)
Citation Context ...unay” surfaces. They obey a nonlinear equation expressing H = H 0 . Deuling and Helfrich used this equation in ref. [32]. There is however a very simple geometrical characterization of these surfaces =-=[46]-=-: 33 .Draw a line ℓ in the plane. Construct any ellipse, tangent at one point to ℓ. Let the ellipse roll without slipping along ℓ, and follow the path of one focus to get a curve C. The figure of rev... |