Abstract

In this paper we prove theoretically and demonstrate empirically that all existing measures of incumbency advantage in the congressional elections literature are biased or inconsistent. We then provide an unbiased estimator based on a very simple linear regression model. We apply this new method to congressional elections since 1900, providing the first evidence of a positive incumbency advantage in the first half of the century.

Citations

35	Statistical Methods for Social, Scientists - Hanushek, Jackson - 1977
27	Congress: Keystone of the Washington Establishment - Fiorina - 1977
24	The Statistical Analysis of Quasi-Experiments - Achen - 1986
24	The Personal Vote: Constituency Service and Electoral - Cain, Ferejohn, et al. - 1987
11	Congressional elections: The case of the vanishing marginals, Polity 6: 295–317 - Mayhew - 1974
10	The Advantage of Incumbency - Erikson - 1971
9	The Marginals Never Vanished: Incumbency and Competition in Elections to the U.S - Jacobson - 1987
8	Congressional Dynamics and the Decline of Competitive Congressional Elections - Cover, Mayhew - 1977
6	How Not to Lie with Statistics: Avoiding - King - 1986
6	The Effects of Charges of Corruption on Voting - Peters, Welch - 1980
4	The Incumbency Effect in Congressional Elections: A Test of Two Explanations - Krehbiel, Wright - 1983
3	On the decline of competition in congressional elections - Ferejohn - 1977
2	Increased incumbency advantage in the House - Alford, Hibbing - 1981
2	The Marginals Never Vanished - Ansolabehere, Brady, et al. - 1988
2	Generational Replacement and the Growth of Incumbent Reelection in the U.S - Born - 1979
2	Congressional Elections - Hinckley - 1981
2	The personal electoral advantage of House incumbents - Payne - 1980
1	Partisan and Incumbent Advantage in U.S - Alford, Brady - 1988
1	Appendix. The British General Election of1950 - Butler - 1951
1	Change in the Vote Margins for Congressional Candidates: A Specification of the Historical Trends - Garand, Gross - 1984
1	Party and Incumbency in Postwar Senate Elections - Kostroski - 1973