Abstract

Similarities between Pavlovian conditioning in nonhumans and causal judgment by humans suggest that similar processes operate in these situations. Notably absent among the similarities is backward blocking (i.e., retrospective devaluation of a signal due to increased valuation of another signal that was present during training), which has been observed in causal judgment by humans but not in Pavlovian responding by animals. The authors used rats to determine if this difference arises from the target cue being biologically significant in the Pavlovian case but not in causal judgment. They used a sensory preconditioning procedure in Experiments 1 and 2, in which the target cue retained low biological significance during the treatment, and obtained backward blocking. The authors found in Experiment 3 that forward blocking also requires the target cue to be of low biological significance. Thus, low biological significance is a necessary condition for a stimulus to be vulnerable to blocking. In recent years, numerous researchers have remarked on the similarity of the conditions that encourage the acquisition of causal relationships in humans and those that foster

Citations

303	A theory of Pavlovian conditioning: variations in the effectiveness of reinforcement and nonreinforcement - Rescorla, Wagner - 1972
266	A Treatise of Human Nature - Hume - 1962
154	Conditional Reflexes - Pavlov - 1927
54	Forward and backward blocking in human contingency judgment - Shanks - 1985
46	Attention-like" processes in classical conditioning - Kamin - 1968
39	Associative accounts of causality judgment - Shanks - 1987
38	Cue competition in causality judgments. The role of nonpresentation of compound stimulus elements - Hamme, Wasserman - 1994
36	Within-compound associations mediate the retrospective revaluation of causality judgements - Dickinson, Burke - 1996
35	Human contingency judgments: Rule based or associative - Allan - 1993
32	Judgement of act–outcome contingency: The role of selective attribution - Dickinson, Shanks, et al. - 1984
29	The comparator hypothesis: A response rule for the expression of associations - Miller, Matzel - 1988
26	Trial order affects cue interaction in contingency judgment - Chapman - 1991
20	Assessment of an information integration account of contingency judgment with examination of subjective cell importance and method of information presentation - Kao, Wasserman - 1993
16	Attribution of causality to common and distinctive elements of compound stimuli - Wasserman - 1990
13	Spreading association in time - Gibbon, Balsam - 1981
13	LMS rules and the inverse base-rate effect: Comment on Gluck and Bower - Markman - 1989
11	Configural and elemental strategies in predictive learning - Williams, Sagness, et al. - 1994
9	A nonassociative aspect of overshadowing - Kaufman, Bolles - 1981
8	Recovery of an overshadowed association achieved by extinction of the overshadowing stimulus - Matzel, Schachtman, et al. - 1985
8	Judging interevent relations: From cause to effect and from effect to cause - Hamme, Kao, et al. - 1993
8	Stimulus selection and ‘modified continuity theory’. In The psychology of learning and motivation - Wagner - 1969
5	Associations in second-order conditioning and sensory preconditioning - Rizley, Rescorla - 1972
5	The least mean squares network with information coding: A model of cue learning - Tassoni - 1995
4	Contingency effects with maintained instrumental reinforcement - Dickinson, Charnock - 1985
4	Overshadowing and stimulus intensity - Mackintosh - 1948
4	Blocking observed in human eyelid conditioning - Martin, Levey - 1991
4	Inflation of comparator stimuli following CS training - Miller, Hallam, et al. - 1990
4	Conditioning context as an associative baseline: Implications for response generation and the nature of conditioned inhibition - Miller, Schachtman - 1985
3	The role of interference in associations over a delay - Revusky - 1971
2	Blocking as a retrieval failure: Reactivation of associations to a blocked stimulus - Balaz, Gutsin, et al. - 1981
2	Context specificity of conditioning in flavor-aversion learning: Extinction and blocking tests - Bonardi, Honey - 1999
2	Loss of control by a less valid or by a less salient stimulus compounded with a better predictor of reinforcement - Hall, Mackintosh, et al. - 1977
2	Failure to attenuate blocking by posttraining extinction of a blocking stimulus]. Unpublished raw data - Miller, Schachtman, et al. - 1987
2	Associative and statistical accounts of cue competition in causality judgments. Unpublished doctoral dissertation - Hamme - 1994
1	Retrieval variability: Sources and consequences - Miller, Kasprow, et al. - 1986
1	Testing the Revised RescorlaWagner model's explanation of backward blocking. Manuscript submitted for publication - Miller, Matute - 1996
1	Reevaluation of things past: A test of the "retrospective hypothesis" using a CER procedure in rats - Schweitzer, Green - 1982
1	Comparative cognition: Toward a general understanding of cognition in behavior - Wasserman - 1993