## The Great Equalizer? Consumer Choice Behavior at Internet Shopbots (2000)

Venue: | SLOAN SCHOOL OF MANAGEMENT, MIT |

Citations: | 32 - 0 self |

### BibTeX

@INPROCEEDINGS{Brynjolfsson00thegreat,

author = {Erik Brynjolfsson and Michael D. Smith},

title = {The Great Equalizer? Consumer Choice Behavior at Internet Shopbots },

booktitle = {SLOAN SCHOOL OF MANAGEMENT, MIT},

year = {2000},

publisher = {}

}

### Years of Citing Articles

### OpenURL

### Abstract

Our research empirically analyzes consumer behavior at Internet shopbots — sites that allow consumers to make “one-click ” price comparisons for product offerings from multiple retailers. By allowing researchers to observe exactly what information the consumer is shown and their search behavior in response to this information, shopbot data has unique strengths for analyzing consumer behavior. Furthermore, the method in which the data is displayed to consumers lends itself to a utility-based evaluation process, consistent with econometric analysis techniques. While price is an important determinant of customer choice, we find that, even among shopbot consumers, branded retailers and retailers a consumer visited previously hold significant price advantages in head-to-head price comparisons. Further, customers are very sensitive to how the total price is allocated among the item price, the shipping cost, and tax, and are also quite sensitive to the ordinal ranking of retailer offerings with respect to price. We also find that consumers use brand as a proxy for a retailer’s credibility with regard to non-contractible aspects of the product bundle such as shipping time. In each case our models accurately predict consumer behavior out of sample, suggesting

### Citations

2533 | Estimating the dimension of a model - Schwarz - 1978 |

1397 |
Information theory and an extension of the maximum likelihood principle
- Akaike
- 1973
(Show Context)
Citation Context ...formation theory, these models better account for both the fit and parsimony of the different candidate models. Notable information theoretic measures include the Akaike Information Criterion or AIC (=-=Akaike 1973-=-), Bayesian Information Criterion or BIC (Schwartz 1987, Raferty 1997), and information theoretic measure of complexity or ICOMP (Bozdogan 1990; Bearse, Bozdogan, Schlottmann 1997, a more recent test,... |

1090 |
Conditional logit analysis of qualitative choice behavior
- McFadden
- 1974
(Show Context)
Citation Context ...is motivated, in part, because it is an approximation to a normal distribution. However, the assumption has the even more desirable property that it dramatically simplifies (4) to the following form (=-=McFadden 1974-=-): τ i ∑ τ = 1 µ β ′ xit e Pt ( x i, β ) = (6) µ β ′ xiτ e This formula has all the desirable properties of a purchase probability: it is always positive, it sums to 1 over all the τ i offers in sessi... |

595 |
Data Reduction and Error Analysis for the Physical Sciences
- Bevington, Robinson
- 1992
(Show Context)
Citation Context ...own in Table 9.The Great Equalizer 34 To allow for statistical comparison of our normalized coefficients we use the fact that for two random variables a and b, the variance of f ( a, b) is given by (=-=Bevington 1992-=-) as σ 2 f 2 2 ⎛ ∂f ⎞ 2 ⎛ ∂f ⎞ 2 = ⎜ ⎟ σ a + ⎜ ⎟ σ b (15) ⎝ ∂a ⎠ ⎝ ∂b ⎠ For f ( a, b) = a / b and using our unbiased estimates of standard deviation this simplifies to s 2 f ⎡ ⎢⎜ ⎟ ⎢⎣ ⎝ a ⎠ ⎤ ⎜ ⎟ ⎥ ⎝ ... |

510 |
Discrete Choice Analysis: Theory and Application to Travel Demand
- Ben-Akiva, Leerman
- 1985
(Show Context)
Citation Context ...our logit model predictions must be understood as being conditioned on a consumer choosing to use a shopbot. Conditioning on prior consumer choice in this way does not bias multinomial logit results (=-=Ben-Akiva and Lerman 1985-=-). Furthermore, in analyzing the effect of this self-selection bias on our results, it seems reasonable to assume that shopbot consumers are more price sensitive than typical Internet consumers are. T... |

328 |
Reducing buyers search costs: implications for electronic marketplaces, Management Science 43
- Bakos
- 1997
(Show Context)
Citation Context ...stance these factors should serve to increase competition and reduce retailer margins in markets served by shopbots — an effect that should be felt most strongly for homogeneous physical goods (e.g., =-=Bakos 1997-=-). One wonders, then, what will happen to a retailer’s brand equity and consumer loyalty in the presence of shopbots. Amazon.com has invested hundreds of millions of dollars in developing its online b... |

290 | A method of simulated moments for estimation of discrete response models without numerical integration - McFadden - 1989 |

290 | Bayesian model selection in social research - Raftery - 1995 |

260 |
Prices and advertising signals of product quality
- Milgrom, Roberts
- 1986
(Show Context)
Citation Context ...umers’ information acquisition costs, lower the risk they must incur when making purchases, and ultimately increase their expected. Brand signals can be communicated to consumers through advertising (=-=Milgrom and Roberts 1986-=-) and through prior personal evaluation (Erdem and Keane 1996). Extending the information economics model of brand value to the Internet, Erdem et al (forthcoming), argue that the Internet may have a ... |

161 | as a constraint on profit seeking: entitlements in the market - Kahneman, Knetsch, et al. - 1986 |

151 |
A Probabilistic Choice Model for Market Segmentation and Elasticity Structure
- Kamakura, Russell
- 1989
(Show Context)
Citation Context ...nd Little (1983) used these data to estimate a multinomial logit model to analyze attribute-based consumer decision making in a retail environment. The results and extensions of their research (e.g., =-=Kamakura and Russell 1989-=-; Fader and Hardie 1996) have since been widely applied by academic researchers and by industry analysts for market forecasting, new product development, and pricing analysis. Today continued reductio... |

123 |
A Conditional Probit Model for Qualitative Choice: Discrete Decisions Recognizing Interdependence and Heterogeneous Preferences." Econometrica 48
- Hausman, Wise
- 1978
(Show Context)
Citation Context ...e shared coefficients by normalizing to a common reference point. We discuss this in more detail in the analysis section. 3.3. Alternate Models and Estimation Techniques The multinomial probit model (=-=Hausman and Wise 1978-=-) is the most recognized alternative to the logitbased models of choice described above. This model assumes that the discrete choice errors are normally distributed. The advantage of this assumption i... |

122 |
Decision-making Under Uncertainty: Capturing Dynamic Brand Choice
- Erdem, Keane
- 1996
(Show Context)
Citation Context ...cur when making purchases, and ultimately increase their expected. Brand signals can be communicated to consumers through advertising (Milgrom and Roberts 1986) and through prior personal evaluation (=-=Erdem and Keane 1996-=-). Extending the information economics model of brand value to the Internet, Erdem et al (forthcoming), argue that the Internet may have a differential effect on brand value depending on the nature of... |

121 |
A Logit Model of Brand Choice Calibrated on Scanner Data
- Guadagni, Little
- 1983
(Show Context)
Citation Context ...hereby uniquely identify the consumer’s computer.The Great Equalizer 11 Using our consumer and click-through data we construct two additional variables to help us control for consumer heterogeneity (=-=Guadagni and Little 1983-=-) and to track consumer loyalty over time: Prior Click, and Prior Last Click. Prior Click is a dummy variable taking on the value 1 for retailers the consumer clicked on in the most recent visit but d... |

107 | Understanding Digital Markets: Review and Assessment,” Working paper 4211-01 - Smith, Bailey, et al. - 2001 |

104 | An Exact Likelihood Analysis of the Multinomial Probit Model
- McCullough, Rossi
- 1994
(Show Context)
Citation Context ...ctical in our setting. In its place, our use of the nested logit model should control for IIA concerns across branded and unbranded retailers.The Great Equalizer 22 Hierarchical Bayesian Estimation (=-=McCulloch and Rossi 1994-=-) provides an individual-level estimation alternative for both logit- and probit-based models. Hierarchical Bayesian Estimation uses Bayesian techniques to estimate individual-level responses for each... |

90 |
Intermediation and Electronic Markets: Aggregation and Pricing
- Bailey
- 1998
(Show Context)
Citation Context ...es set by retailers, not just the retailers’ pricing behavior. Research analyzing retailer pricing strategies has been used to characterize the relative efficiency of electronic and physical markets (=-=Bailey 1998-=-; Brynjolfsson and Smith 2000), retailer differentiation strategies (Clay, Krishnan, Wolff, Fernandes 1999), and price discrimination strategies (Clemons, Hann, and Hitt 1998). However, retailer prici... |

64 |
Product Differentiation and Oligopoly in International Markets: The case of U.S
- Goldberg
- 1995
(Show Context)
Citation Context ...l nested model is chosen here for expositional simplicity and its applicability to our setting. Nested models containing 3 or more nests are simple extensions of the two-level nested logit model (see =-=Goldberg 1995-=- for an empirical example of a five-level model).The Great Equalizer 20 least one element of Cn and the conditional retailer choice set, Rns, as the subset of all retailers available to consumer n co... |

55 | The value of purchase history data in target marketing. Marketing Sci - Rossi, McCulloch, et al. - 1996 |

51 |
The role of scale parameter in the estimation and comparison of multinomial logit models
- Swait, Louviere
- 1993
(Show Context)
Citation Context ...it is possible to analyze the β parameters within nests. However, the scale parameter will not be constant across nests in general, making it impossible to directly compare coefficients across nests (=-=Swait and Louviere 1993-=-). However, it is possible to compare shared coefficients by normalizing to a common reference point. We discuss this in more detail in the analysis section. 3.3. Alternate Models and Estimation Techn... |

48 |
Modeling Consumer Choice Among SKUs
- Fader, Hardie
- 1996
(Show Context)
Citation Context ... data to estimate a multinomial logit model to analyze attribute-based consumer decision making in a retail environment. The results and extensions of their research (e.g., Kamakura and Russell 1989; =-=Fader and Hardie 1996-=-) have since been widely applied by academic researchers and by industry analysts for market forecasting, new product development, and pricing analysis. Today continued reductions in computing cost an... |

41 |
Brand Choice, Purchase Incidence and Segmentation: An Integrated Modeling Approach
- Bucklin, Gupta
- 1992
(Show Context)
Citation Context ...iya 1978). However, it has been shown that in many applications the resulting standard errors are not significantly different from those resulting from Full-Information Maximum Likelihood estimation (=-=Bucklin and Gupta 1992-=-, p. 205). Given the strong significance of nearly all our coefficient estimates it is highly unlikely that Full Information Maximum Likelihood estimation would change our results. Table 11: Nested Lo... |

38 | Brand equity as a signaling phenomenon - Erdem, Swait - 1998 |

38 |
Creating Micro-Marketing Pricing Strategies Using Supermarket Scanner Data
- Montgomery
- 1997
(Show Context)
Citation Context ...hile still allowing for a correlated error structure. However, hierarchical Bayesian techniques are typically used to analyze individual level consumer response (e.g., Rossi, McCulloch, Allenby 1996; =-=Montgomery 1997-=-). Given the separation between shopbots and retailers, individualized pricing strategies are not currently used in shopbot markets making Hierarchical Bayesian techniques less appropriate for our ana... |

30 | Retail strategies on the Web: Price and non-price competition in the online book industry - Clay, Krishnan, et al. - 2002 |

29 |
On the information-based measure of covariance complexity and its application to the evaluation of multivariate linear models
- Bozdogan
- 1990
(Show Context)
Citation Context ... measures include the Akaike Information Criterion or AIC (Akaike 1973), Bayesian Information Criterion or BIC (Schwartz 1987, Raferty 1997), and information theoretic measure of complexity or ICOMP (=-=Bozdogan 1990-=-; Bearse, Bozdogan, Schlottmann 1997, a more recent test, which uses the Fisher information matrix. These criteria are discussed in more detail in Appendix C. For each model in Table 10, we present th... |

25 | A note on Bayes factors for log-linear contingency tables with vague prior information - Raftery - 1986 |

23 | Divide and Prosper: Consumers' Reactions to Partitioned Prices - Greenleaf, Johnson - 1998 |

18 | The Emerging Role of - Bakos - 1998 |

11 |
On a two-step estimate of a multivariate logit model
- Amemiya
- 1978
(Show Context)
Citation Context ...n-Akiva and Lerman (1985, pp. 297-298) and Guadagni and Little (1998). Sequential estimation produces consistent but asymptotically inefficient estimates, causing the standard errors to be too small (=-=Amemiya 1978-=-). However, it has been shown that in many applications the resulting standard errors are not significantly different from those resulting from Full-Information Maximum Likelihood estimation (Bucklin ... |

8 | Empirical econometric modelling of food consumption using a new informational complexity approach - Bearse, Bozdogan, et al. - 1997 |

8 | Missing Prices and Coupon Availability Data in Scanner Panels: Correcting for the Self-selection bias in Choice Models Parameters - Erdem, Keane, et al. - 1999 |

8 |
When and What to Buy: A Nested Logit Model of Coffee Purchase
- Guadagni, Little
- 1998
(Show Context)
Citation Context ...of brand, retailer, and the joint choice of brand and retailer. We additionally assume that 1. var(er)=0, which is equivalent to assuming independence of choice alternatives in the bottom level nest (=-=Guadagni and Little 1998-=-); 2. es and esr are independent for brand and retailer selections in the consumer’s choice set; 3. the esr terms are independent and identically Gumbel distributed with a scale parameter µ r , and 4.... |

7 | a World Without Borders: The Impact of Taxes on Internet Commerce,” Quarterly - “In |

6 | What makes a web site “sticky”? Cognitive lock in and the power law of practice - Johnson, Bellman, et al. - 2003 |

2 |
An approximate distribution of variance components
- Satterthwaite
- 1946
(Show Context)
Citation Context ...hypothesis that the normalized coefficients are equal using the standard ttest for µ a = µ b with a σ and b σ unknown and b σ a σ ≠ a −b t = (17) 2 2 sa sb + n n a b with degrees of freedom given by (=-=Satterthwaite 1946-=-)The Great Equalizer 35 ( n −1) ( n −1) 2 2 2 ⎛ s ⎞ a sb ⎜ + ⎟ ⎝ na nb ν = ⎠ (18) 2 2 2 2 ⎛ s ⎞ ⎛ ⎞ a sb ⎜ ⎟ ⎜ ⎟ ⎝ na ⎠ + ⎝ nb ⎠ a b Under this test, we reject the null hypothesis for average deliver... |

1 | Using strategic tools to generate profits in e-commerce. Sloan Management Review forthcoming - Figueiredo - 2000 |