## Relating first-order set theories, toposes and categories of classes (2006)

Venue: | In preparation |

Citations: | 3 - 3 self |

### BibTeX

@INPROCEEDINGS{Awodey06relatingfirst-order,

author = {Steve Awodey and Thomas Streicher},

title = {Relating first-order set theories, toposes and categories of classes},

booktitle = {In preparation},

year = {2006}

}

### OpenURL

### Abstract

This paper introduces Basic Intuitionistic Set Theory BIST, and investigates it as a first-order set-theory extending the internal logic of elementary toposes. Given an elementary topos, together with the extra structure of a directed structural system of inclusions (dssi) on the topos, a forcing-style interpretation of the language of first-order set theory in the topos is given, which conservatively extends the internal logic of the topos. Since every topos is equivalent to one carrying a dssi, the language of first-order has a forcing interpretation in every elementary topos. We prove that the set theory BIST+ Coll (where Coll is the strong Collection axiom) is sound and complete relative to forcing interpretations in toposes with natural numbers object (nno). Furthermore, in the case that the structural system of inclusions is superdirected, the full Separation schema is modelled. We show that every cocomplete topos and every realizability topos can be endowed (up to equivalence) with such a superdirected structural system of inclusions. This provides a uniform explanation for why such “real-world ” toposes model Separation. A large part of the paper is devoted to an alternative notion of category-theoretic model for BIST, which, following the general approach of Joyal and Moerdijk’s Algebraic Set Theory, axiomatizes the structure possessed by categories of classes compatible with ∗Corresponding author. 1Previously, lecturer at Heriot-Watt University (2000–2001), and the IT University of

### Citations

424 |
Introduction to Higher Order Categorical Logic
- Lambek, Scott
- 1986
(Show Context)
Citation Context ...elementary topos as themselves being “sets” according to a generalised notion of set. Specifically, elementary toposes possess an internal logic, which is a form of higher-order type theory. see e.g. =-=[28, 8, 30, 24]-=-, and which allows one to reason with objects of the topos as if they were abstract sets in the sense of [29]; that is, as if they were collections of elements. The reasoning supported by the internal... |

149 |
Sketches of an elephant: a topos theory compendium
- Johnstone
- 2002
(Show Context)
Citation Context ...elementary topos as themselves being “sets” according to a generalized notion of set. Specifically, elementary toposes possess an internal logic, which is a form of higher-order type theory. see e.g. =-=[25, 7, 27, 22]-=-, and which allows one to reason with objects of the topos as if they were abstract sets in the sense of [26]; that is, as if they were collections of elements. The reasoning supported by the internal... |

119 |
The type theoretic interpretation of constructive set theory
- Aczel
- 2001
(Show Context)
Citation Context ...6]) considers set theories with unrestricted Replacement or Collection axioms. In having such principles, our set theories are similar to the “constructive” set theories of Myhill, Friedman and Aczel =-=[34, 16, 1, 3]-=-. However, because of our acceptance of the Powerset axiom, none of the set theories presented in this section are “constructive” in the sense of these authors. 10 In fact, in comparison with Aczel’s ... |

80 |
The effective topos
- Hyland
- 1982
(Show Context)
Citation Context ...or example, all cocomplete toposes (and hence all Grothendieck toposes) enjoy this property; see Fourman [14] and Hayashi [18] for two different accounts of this. Similarly, all realizability toposes =-=[20, 21]-=- also model IZF, as follows, for example, from McCarty’s realizability interpretation of IZF [30]. Thus, if one 7is primarily interested in such “real world” toposes, then the account above is unsati... |

61 |
Models for Smooth Infinitesimal Analysis
- Moerdijk, Reyes
- 1991
(Show Context)
Citation Context ...f mathematical interest are not boolean. The use of intuitionistic logic is thus an inevitable feature of internal reasoning in toposes. Furthermore, as fields such as synthetic differential geometry =-=[33]-=- and synthetic domain theory [19] demonstrate, the non-validity of classical logic is a strength rather than a weakness of the internal logic. In these areas, intuitionistic logic offers the opportunt... |

53 |
First steps in synthetic domain theory
- Hyland
- 1991
(Show Context)
Citation Context ...an. The use of intuitionistic logic is thus an inevitable feature of internal reasoning in toposes. Furthermore, as fields such as synthetic differential geometry [37, 26] and synthetic domain theory =-=[22]-=- demonstrate, the non-validity of classical logic is a strength rather than a weakness of the internal logic. In these areas, intuitionistic logic offers the opportunity of working consistently with u... |

49 |
Constructive set theory
- Myhill
- 1975
(Show Context)
Citation Context ...dd such constants and assume Nat(N, 0, s) (instead of our axiom of Infinity) and hence avoid the fuss. (Indeed this is common practice in the formulation of weak intuitionistic set theories, see e.g. =-=[34, 42]-=-.) Our reason for not doing so is that, in Parts II–III, we shall consider various semantic models of the first-order language and we should like it to be a property of such models whether or not they... |

44 | Notes on constructive set theory
- Aczel, Rathjen
- 2001
(Show Context)
Citation Context ... ∈ y . This is important in the formulation of the Powerset axiom. We also use the notation x. φ, which abbreviates S ∃y. (S(y) ∧ ∀x. (x ∈ y ↔ φ)) , where y is a variable not occurring free in φ (cf. =-=[3]-=-). Thus x. φ states that the class {x | φ} forms a set. Equivalently, can be understood as a generalized quantifier, reading x. φ as “there are set-many x satisfying φ”. S S S Often we shall consider ... |

42 |
Set Theory
- Kuratowski, Mostowski
- 1967
(Show Context)
Citation Context ...T). Although very natural, and based on familiar looking set-theoretic axioms, there are several differences compared with standard formulations of intuitionistic set theories, such as Friedman’s IZF =-=[15, 16, 42]-=-. Two of the differences are minor: in BIST the universe may contain non-sets as well as sets, and non-well-founded sets are permitted (though not obliged to exist). These differences are inessential ... |

37 | Wellfounded trees in categories
- Moerdijk, Palmgren
- 2000
(Show Context)
Citation Context ...neral classes of pretoposes, relating these to “predicative” (or “constructive”) versions of BIST, via axioms for small maps generalising those of the present paper. A parallel project, starting with =-=[31, 32]-=-, has generalised the original axioms for small maps from Joyal and Moerdijk [23] to the “predicative” (“constructive”) case, focusing in particular on incorporating well-founded trees (W-types) in th... |

35 | Type theories, toposes, and constructive set theories: predicative aspects of AST, Annals of Pure and Applied Logic 114
- Moerdijk, Palmgren
- 2002
(Show Context)
Citation Context ... the category of classes that are compatible with a very weak (predicative) constructive set theory. Although the study of such predicative set theories is outside the scope of the present paper (cf. =-=[32, 6, 41]-=-), the notion of basic class structure nonetheless serves the purpose of identifying the basic category-theoretic structure of categories of classes. Second, in Section 6, we consider the additional p... |

29 |
Relating theories of the lambda-calculus
- Scott
- 1980
(Show Context)
Citation Context ... set-theoretic universe within a typed world of classes may be seen as analogous to Dana Scott’s identification of models of the untyped λ-calculus as reflexive objects in cartesian closed categories =-=[37]-=-. The stronger notion of universal object enforces that every class can be seen as a subclass of the untyped universe U. This situation occurs naturally in first-order set theory, where classes are de... |

27 |
Realizability and Recursive Mathematics
- McCarty
- 1984
(Show Context)
Citation Context ...man [14] and Hayashi [18] for two different accounts of this. Similarly, all realizability toposes [20, 21] also model IZF, as follows, for example, from McCarty’s realizability interpretation of IZF =-=[30]-=-. Thus, if one 7is primarily interested in such “real world” toposes, then the account above is unsatisfactory in merely detailing how to interpret the weak set theory BIST inside them. To address th... |

25 |
Elementary axioms for categories of classes
- Simpson
- 1999
(Show Context)
Citation Context ..., imposing sufficient structure for these to model Friedman’s IZF set theory. Their axiomatic structure was later refined by the third author, who obtained a corresponding completeness result for IZF =-=[39]-=- (see also [12] for related work). In this paper we are interested in axiomatizing the structure on a category of classes suitable for modelling the set theory BIST of Part I. We introduce this in two... |

24 |
Set-theoretic foundations for constructive analysis
- Friedman
- 1977
(Show Context)
Citation Context ...T). Although very natural, and based on familiar looking set-theoretic axioms, there are several differences compared with standard formulations of intuitionistic set theories, such as Friedman’s IZF =-=[15, 16, 42]-=-. Two of the differences are minor: in BIST the universe may contain non-sets as well as sets, and non-well-founded sets are permitted (though not obliged to exist). These differences are inessential ... |

22 |
Sheaf models for set theory
- Fourman
- 1980
(Show Context)
Citation Context ...) are able to model Friedman’s IZF set theory, which is proof-theoretically as strong as ZFC. For example, all cocomplete toposes (and hence all Grothendieck toposes) enjoy this property; see Fourman =-=[14]-=- and Hayashi [18] for two different accounts of this. Similarly, all realizability toposes [20, 21] also model IZF, as follows, for example, from McCarty’s realizability interpretation of IZF [30]. Th... |

21 |
The consistency of classical set theory relative to a set theory with intuitionistic logic
- Friedman
- 1973
(Show Context)
Citation Context ...T). Although very natural, and based on familiar looking set-theoretic axioms, there are several differences compared with standard formulations of intuitionistic set theories, such as Friedman’s IZF =-=[15, 16, 42]-=-. Two of the differences are minor: in BIST the universe may contain non-sets as well as sets, and non-well-founded sets are permitted (though not obliged to exist). These differences are inessential ... |

17 | Bernays-Gödel type theory
- Butz
(Show Context)
Citation Context ...icient structure for these to model Friedman’s IZF set theory. Their axiomatic structure was later refined by the third author, who obtained a corresponding completeness result for IZF [39] (see also =-=[12]-=- for related work). In this paper we are interested in axiomatizing the structure on a category of classes suitable for modelling the set theory BIST of Part I. We introduce this in two stages. In Sec... |

16 |
Non-well-founded sets, volume 14 of CSLI Lecture Notes
- Aczel
- 1988
(Show Context)
Citation Context ...et theory BINWFA replaces the two axioms R∈-Ind and MC with AFA, which is a straightforward adaptation, to a universe with atoms, of Honsell and Forti’s Anti-Foundation Axiom, as popularized by Aczel =-=[2]-=-. Formally, the axiom AFA is simply a strengthening of MC with the well-foundedness assumption on the membership graph dropped. Because well-foundedness is no longer assumed, in the case of AFA it is ... |

14 |
Categorical set theory: a characterization of the category of sets
- Osius
- 1974
(Show Context)
Citation Context ...pos E, certain “transitive objects” can be identified, out of which a model of bZ can be constructed. This model captures that part of the internal logic of E that pertains to transitive objects. See =-=[27, 7, 36]-=- for accounts of this correspondence. 3 Also known as “Mac Lane” set theory [29]. 4This standard story is unsatisfactory in several respects. First, it applies only to well-pointed (hence boolean) to... |

13 | Nuclear Theory (W - Lane - 1964 |

12 | Algebraic models of intuitionistic theories of sets and classes. Theory and Applications of Categories 15(1
- Awodey, Forssell
- 2005
(Show Context)
Citation Context ...mpletion of the paper was delayed by various circumstances and, meanwhile, there have been several further developments in algebraic set theory, some of which build on the approach presented here. In =-=[5]-=-, Awodey and Forssell have given an account of the ideals construction avoiding the need for a system of inclusions. For an arbitrary Π-pretopos E they consider the category Sh(E) of coherent sheaves ... |

12 | The Strength of Mac Lane Set Theory
- Mathias
(Show Context)
Citation Context ...e constructed. This model captures that part of the internal logic of E that pertains to transitive objects. See [27, 7, 36] for accounts of this correspondence. 3 Also known as “Mac Lane” set theory =-=[29]-=-. 4This standard story is unsatisfactory in several respects. First, it applies only to well-pointed (hence boolean) toposes. Second, by only expressing properties of transitive objects in E, whole s... |

8 | Aspects of Predicative Algebraic Set Theory I: Exact Completions, ArXiv:0710.3077v1
- Berg, Moerdijk
- 2007
(Show Context)
Citation Context ...e” (“constructive”) case, focusing in particular on incorporating well-founded trees (W-types) in the theory. This programme has recently culminated in a series of papers by van den Berg and Moerdijk =-=[9, 8, 11, 10]-=-, which provides a general axiomatization encompassing also the categories of ideals. One characteristic of these papers is a focus on more familiar intuitionistic set theories (IZF, CZF) rather than ... |

8 |
Algebraic set theory. Number 220
- Joyal, Moerdijk
- 1995
(Show Context)
Citation Context ...ssary to ensure that the property it asserts is preserved by slicing. Both modifications are taken account of simultaneously in property 1 of the proposition below, which is due to Joyal and Moerdijk =-=[23]-=-. Proposition 6.6. The following are equivalent. 1. For every small A ✲ I and regular epi X ✲✲ A, there exists a quasipullback diagram18 B ✲ X ✲✲ A ❄ J with J ✲✲ I regular epi and B ✲ J small. ❄ ✲✲ I ... |

8 | Computational adequacy for recursive types in models of intuitionistic set theory
- Simpson
- 2004
(Show Context)
Citation Context ...hism is regular, thus 4 =⇒ 2. 59(Separation) The equivalent conditions of Proposition 6.4 hold. Using item 1 of Proposition 6.4, it is immediate that the Separation axiom is preserved by slicing. In =-=[39, 40]-=-, categories with basic class structure satisfying both Powerset and Separation were considered under the description categories with class(ic) structure. As shown in [39], it is possible to give an e... |

8 | Synthetic differential geometry, volume 333 of London Mathematical Society Lecture Note Series - Kock - 2006 |

8 |
Oosten, Algebraic Set Theory and the Effective Topos
- Kouwenhoven-Gentil, van
- 2005
(Show Context)
Citation Context ...ounts to an equivalence between McCarty’s model of IZF and the associated realizability topos. It would be interesting to compare this equivalence with the result of Kouwenhoven-Gentil and van Oosten =-=[27]-=- (see also [39, §3.5.1]), where McCarty’s interpretation of IZF is shown to coincide with the interpretation of IZF given by an initial “ZF-algebra”, in the sense of [25], in RT(A) (assuming an inacce... |

8 | Constructive set theories and their category-theoretic models. In: From Sets and Types to Topology and Analysis
- Simpson
- 2005
(Show Context)
Citation Context ... the category of classes that are compatible with a very weak (predicative) constructive set theory. Although the study of such predicative set theories is outside the scope of the present paper (cf. =-=[36, 7, 45]-=-), the notion of basic class structure nonetheless serves the purpose of identifying the basic category-theoretic structure of categories of classes. Second, in Section 6, we consider the additional p... |

7 | Predicative algebraic set theory
- Awodey, Warren
(Show Context)
Citation Context ... the category of classes that are compatible with a very weak (predicative) constructive set theory. Although the study of such predicative set theories is outside the scope of the present paper (cf. =-=[32, 6, 41]-=-), the notion of basic class structure nonetheless serves the purpose of identifying the basic category-theoretic structure of categories of classes. Second, in Section 6, we consider the additional p... |

7 |
The lack of definable witnesses and provably recursive functions in intuitionistic set theories
- Friedman, A
- 1985
(Show Context)
Citation Context ...ngth. Similarly, IST+ Coll and IZF+ Coll have equivalent strength. It is known, [42, Section 3], that IZF+ Coll, and hence IST+ Coll, proves the same Π0 2-sentences as classical ZF. It is also known, =-=[17, 42]-=-, that IZF, and hence IST, is strictly weaker than ZF, with regard to Π0 2-sentences. It is an open question whether IZF, and hence IST, proves the same Π0 1 sentences as ZF. We end this section with ... |

6 | Aspects of predicative algebraic set theory II: Realizability. Preliminary version available at [3
- Berg, Moerdijk
(Show Context)
Citation Context ...e” (“constructive”) case, focusing in particular on incorporating well-founded trees (W-types) in the theory. This programme has recently culminated in a series of papers by van den Berg and Moerdijk =-=[9, 8, 11, 10]-=-, which provides a general axiomatization encompassing also the categories of ideals. One characteristic of these papers is a focus on more familiar intuitionistic set theories (IZF, CZF) rather than ... |

6 |
Realizability: An Introduction to its Categorical Side, volume 152
- Oosten
- 2008
(Show Context)
Citation Context ...th respect to specified topos structure on the category. Throughout this section, our meta-theory is ZFC. We briefly recall the construction of realizability toposes. The reader is referred to any of =-=[20, 21, 35]-=- for the omitted details. Throughout this section, 107let (A, ·) be an arbitrary but fixed partial combinatory algebra (pca). A nonstandard predicate on a set X is given by a function from X to P(A).... |

6 |
Categories of sets and models of set theory
- Cole
- 1973
(Show Context)
Citation Context ...pos E, certain “transitive objects” can be identified, out of which a model of bZ can be constructed. This model captures that part of the internal logic of E that pertains to transitive objects. See =-=[34, 14, 40, 30]-=- for accounts of this correspondence. This standard story is unsatisfactory in several respects. First, it applies just to well-pointed (hence boolean) toposes. Second, by only expressing properties 4... |

6 |
Boolean topoi and the theory of sets
- Mitchell
- 1972
(Show Context)
Citation Context ...pos E, certain “transitive objects” can be identified, out of which a model of bZ can be constructed. This model captures that part of the internal logic of E that pertains to transitive objects. See =-=[34, 14, 40, 30]-=- for accounts of this correspondence. This standard story is unsatisfactory in several respects. First, it applies just to well-pointed (hence boolean) toposes. Second, by only expressing properties 4... |

5 |
On set theories and toposes
- Hayashi
- 1980
(Show Context)
Citation Context ...ented in Section 4, using a suitably defined notion of “forcing” over a dssi. We mention that a similar forcing semantics for first-order set theory in toposes was previously introduced by Hayashi in =-=[18]-=-. In op. cit., the notion of inclusion is provided by the canonical notion of inclusion map between the transitive objects in a topos, and the interpretation of first-order set theory is thus only abl... |

5 | Relating first-order set theories, elementary toposes and categories of classes
- Awodey, Butz, et al.
- 2007
(Show Context)
Citation Context ...e cardinal). Related work The research presented in this paper was carried out in a three year period from 2000 to 2003, and the results of Parts I and II of the paper were announced without proof in =-=[5]-=-. The completion of the paper was delayed by various circumstances and, meanwhile, there have been several further developments in algebraic set theory, some of which build on the approach presented h... |

5 |
Moerdijk A unified approach to algebraic set theory
- Berg, I
- 2009
(Show Context)
Citation Context ...e” (“constructive”) case, focusing in particular on incorporating well-founded trees (W-types) in the theory. This programme has recently culminated in a series of papers by van den Berg and Moerdijk =-=[10, 9, 11, 12]-=-, which provides a general axiomatization encompassing also the categories of ideals. One characteristic of these papers is a focus on more familiar intuitionistic set theories (IZF, CZF) rather than ... |

4 | A brief introduction to algebraic set theory. Forthcoming
- Awodey
(Show Context)
Citation Context ...e familiar intuitionistic set theories (IZF, CZF) rather than the non-standard set theories we consider. 115Introductions to the developments mentioned in the previous two paragraphs can be found in =-=[4]-=- and [9] respectively. In a recent preprint [38], Shulman has given an interpretation of a first-order logic allowing quantification over both elements and objects of a pretopos. The ideas behind his ... |

2 |
Sets for Mathematicians
- Lawvere, Roseburgh
- 2003
(Show Context)
Citation Context ...ossess an internal logic, which is a form of higher-order type theory. see e.g. [25, 7, 27, 22], and which allows one to reason with objects of the topos as if they were abstract sets in the sense of =-=[26]-=-; that is, as if they were collections of elements. The reasoning supported by the internal logic is both natural and powerful, but it differs in several respects from the set-theoretic reasoning avai... |

2 |
Stack semantics and the comparison of material and structural set theories
- Shulman
- 2010
(Show Context)
Citation Context ...F) rather than the non-standard set theories we consider. 115Introductions to the developments mentioned in the previous two paragraphs can be found in [4] and [9] respectively. In a recent preprint =-=[38]-=-, Shulman has given an interpretation of a first-order logic allowing quantification over both elements and objects of a pretopos. The ideas behind his interpretation are closely related to the forcin... |

1 |
Toposes and local set theories. Number 14 in Oxford Logic Guides
- Bell
- 1988
(Show Context)
Citation Context ...elementary topos as themselves being “sets” according to a generalized notion of set. Specifically, elementary toposes possess an internal logic, which is a form of higher-order type theory. see e.g. =-=[25, 7, 27, 22]-=-, and which allows one to reason with objects of the topos as if they were abstract sets in the sense of [26]; that is, as if they were collections of elements. The reasoning supported by the internal... |

1 | Algebraic set theory and the effective topos
- Kouwenhoven-Gentil, Oosten
- 1986
(Show Context)
Citation Context ...ounts to an equivalence between McCarty’s model of IZF and the associated realizability topos. It would be interesting to compare this equivalence with the result of Kouwenhoven-Gentil and van Oosten =-=[24]-=- (see also [35, §3.5.1]), where McCarty’s interpretation of IZF is shown to coincide with the interpretation of IZF given by an initial “ZF-algebra”, in the sense of [23], in RT(A) (assuming an inacce... |

1 |
Aspects of topoi. Bulletin of the Australian Mathematical Society, 7(1):1–76
- Freyd
- 1972
(Show Context)
Citation Context ...∼ = X. In the first case e splits by strong projectivity, in the second e is an iso. The following important lemma is reminiscent of the early Freyd embedding theorems for toposes, see section 3.2 of =-=[16]-=-. ✲✲ ❄ A 89Lemma 10.8 (ZFC). Every small category of classes C has a universe-preserving conservative functor C → C ∗ into a category of classes C ∗ in which the terminal object 1 is strongly project... |