Abstract

Abstract. I argue that psychologists interested in human causal judgment should understand and adopt a representation of causal mechanisms by directed graphs that encode conditional independence (screening off) relations. I illustrate the benefits of that representation, now widely used in computer science and increasingly in statistics, by (i) showing that a dispute in psychology between ‘mechanist’ and ‘associationist ’ psychological theories of causation rests on a false and confused dichotomy; (ii) showing that a recent, much-cited experiment, purporting to show that human subjects, incorrectly let large causes ‘overshadow ’ small causes, misrepresents the most likely, and warranted, causal explanation available to the subjects, in the light of which their responses were normative; (iii) showing how a recent psychological theory (due to P. Cheng) of human judgment of causal power can be considerably generalized: and (iv) suggesting a range of possible experiments comparing human and computer abilities to extract causal information from associations.

Citations

5662	Probabilistic reasoning in intelligent systems: networks of plausible inference - Pearl - 1988
383	Causation, prediction, and search - Spirtes, Glymour, et al. - 2000
135	From covariation to causation: A causal power theory. Psychological Review, 104, 367-405. inference and causal learning 69 - Cheng - 1997
132	Causal diagrams for empirical research - Pearl - 1994
54	Covariation in natural causal induction - Cheng - 1992
43	Predictive and diagnostic learning within causal models: Asymmetries in cue competition - Waldmann, Holyoak - 1992
31	A note on measurement of contingency between two binary variables in judgment tasks - Allan - 1980
28	Rules of causal attribution - Shultz - 1982
25	Acting as intuitive scientists: Contingency judgments are made while controlling for alternative potential causes - Spellman - 1996
23	Conditionalizing causality - Spellman - 1996
22	Is human learning rational? Quarterly - Shanks - 1995
21	The relation between conscious and unconscious (automatic) influences: A declaration of independence - Jacoby, Yonelinas, et al. - 1997
20	Causal Powers: A Theory of Natural Necessity - Harre, Madden - 1975
17	Selective associations and causality judgments: Presence of a strong causal factor may reduce judgments of a weaker one - Baker, Mercier, et al. - 1993
15	Judgmental overshadowing: Further evidence of cue interaction in contingency judgment - Price, Yates - 1993
11	Causal attribution as a search for underlying mechanisms - Ahn, Bailenson - 1996
11	Death is the mother of beauty: Mind - Turner - 1987
7	A theory of causal processing - White - 1989
4	Human causal discovery from observational data - Ahmad, Hashem, et al. - 1996
1	The Effect of Representations of Binary Variables on - Allan, Jenkins - 1983
1	Probability of Shock in the Presence and Absence - Rescorla - 1968