Abstract. Optimizing compilers for object-oriented languages apply static class analysis and other techniques to try to deduce precise information about the possible classes of the receivers of messages; if successful, dynamicallydispatched messages can be replaced with direct procedure calls and potentially further optimized through inline-expansion. By examining the complete inheritance graph of a program, which we call class hierarchy analysis, the compiler can improve the quality of static class information and thereby improve run-time performance. In this paper we present class hierarchy analysis and describe techniques for implementing this analysis effectively in both statically- and dynamically-typed languages and also in the presence of multi-methods. We also discuss how class hierarchy analysis can be supported in an interactive programming environment and, to some extent, in the presence of separate compilation. Finally, we assess the bottom-line performance improvement due to class hierarchy analysis alone and in combination with two other “competing ” optimizations, profileguided receiver class prediction and method specialization. 1

Multiple dispatching provides increased expressive power over single dispatching by guiding method lookup using the values of all arguments instead of only the receiver. However, existing languages with multiple dispatching do not encourage the dataabstraction-oriented programming style that is encouraged by traditional single-dispatching languages; instead existing multiple-dispatching languages tend to foster a functionoriented programming style organized around generic functions. We propose an alternative view of multiple dispatching that is intended to promote a data-abstraction-oriented programming style. Instead of viewing a multi-method as “outside ” of all objects, we view a multi-method as “inside ” the objects for which the multi-method applies (on which it dispatches). Because objects are closely connected to the multi-methods implementing their operations, the internals of an object can be encapsulated by being accessible only to the closely-connected multi-methods. We are exploring this object-oriented view of multimethods in the context of a new programming language named Cecil.

Persistent Application Systems (PASs) are of increasing social and economic importance. They have the potential to be long-lived, concurrently accessed and consist of large bodies of data and programs. Typical examples of PASs are CAD/CAM systems, office automation, CASE tools, software engineering environments and patient-care support systems in hospitals. Orthogonally persistent object systems are intended to provide improved support for the design, construction, maintenance and operation of PASs. The persistence abstraction allows the creation and manipulation of data in a manner that is independent of its lifetime thereby integrating the database view of information with the programming language view. This yields a number of advantages in terms of orthogonal design and programmer productivity which are beneficial for PASs. Design principles have been proposed for persistent systems. By following these principles, languages that provide persistence as a basic abstract...

Object-oriented programming languages promise to improve programmer productivity by supporting abstract data types, inheritance, and message passing directly within the language. Unfortunately, traditional implementations of object-oriented language features, particularly message passing, have been much slower than traditional implementations of their non-object-oriented counterparts: the fastest existing implementation of Smalltalk-80 runs at only a tenth the speed of an optimizing C implementation. The dearth of suitable implementation technology has forced most object-oriented languages to be designed as hybrids with traditional non-object-oriented languages, complicating the languages and making programs harder to extend and reuse. This dissertation describes a collection of implementation techniques that can improve the run-time performance of object-oriented languages, in hopes of reducing the need for hybrid languages and encouraging wider spread of purely object-oriented langu...

In the past, object-oriented language designers and programmers have been forced to choose between pure message passing and performance. Last year, our SELF system achieved close to half the speed of optimized C but suffered from impractically long compile times. Two new optimization techniques, deferred compilation of uncommon cases and non-backtracking splitting using path objects, have improved compilation speed by more than an order of magnitude. SELF now compiles about as fast as an optimizing C compiler and runs at over half the speed of optimized C. This new level of performance may make pure object-oriented languages practical. 1 Introduction In the past, object-oriented language designers and programmers have been forced to choose between purity and performance. In a pure object-oriented language, all computation, even low-level operations like variable accessing, arithmetic, and array indexing, is performed by sending messages to objects. Although a message send may cost o...

Cecil is a new purely object-oriented language intended to support rapid construction of highquality, extensible software. Cecil combines multi-methods with a classless object model, object-based encapsulation, and optional static type checking. Cecil's static type system distinguishes between subtyping and code inheritance, but Cecil enables these two graphs to be described with a single set of declarations, optimizing the common case where the two graphs are parallel. Cecil includes a fairly flexible form of parameterization, including both explicitly parameterized objects, types, and methods and implicitly parameterized methods related to the polymorphic functions commonly found in functional languages. By making type declarations optional, Cecil aims to support mixed exploratory and production programming styles. This document describes the design of the Cecil language as of March, 1993. It mixes the specification of the language with discussions of design issues and explanations of...

All object-oriented languages provide support for subtype polymorphism, which allows the writing of generic code that works for families of related types. There is also a need, however, to write code that is generic across types that have no real family relationship. To satisfy this need a programming language must provide a mechanism for parametric polymorphism, allowing for types as parameters to routines and types. We show that to support modular programming and separate compilation there must be a mechanism for constraining the actual parameters of the routine or type. We describe a simple and powerful constraint mechanism and compare it with constraint mechanisms in other languages in terms of both ease of use and semantic expressiveness. We also discuss the interaction between subtype and parametric polymorphism: we discuss the subtype relations that can exist between instantiations of parameterized types, and which of those relations are useful and can be implemented efficiently...

We discuss aspects of inlining of virtual method invocations. First, we introduce a new method test to guard inlinings of such invocations, with a different set of tradeoffs from the class-equality tests proposed previously in the literature. Second, we consider the problem of inlining virtual methods directly, with no guarding test, in dynamic languages such as Self or the Java(tm) programming language, whose semantics prohibit a static identification of the complete set of modules that comprise a program. In non-dynamic languages, a whole-program analysis might prove the correctness of a direct virtual inlining. In dynamic languages, however, such analyses can be invalidated by later class loading, and must therefore be treated as assumptions whose later violation must cause recompilation. In the past, such systems have required an on-stack replacement mechanism to update currently-executing invocations of methods containing invalidated inlinings. This paper presents analyses that allow some virtual calls to be inlined directly even if class loading invalidates the inlining for future invocations. This provides the benefits of direct inlining without the need for on-stack replacement, which can be complicated and require space-consuming data structures.

E is an extension of C++ designed for writing software systems to support persistent applications. Originally designed as a language for implementing database systems, E has evolved into a general persistent programming language E was the first C++ extension to support transparent persistence, the first C++ implementation to support generic classes, and remains the only C++ extension to provide general-purpose lterators, In addition to its contributions to the C + + programming domain, work on E has made several contributions to the field of persmtent languages in general, including several distinct implementations of persistence. Thm paper describes the main features of E and shows through examples how E addresses many of the problems that arise in building persistent systems.

Cecil is a purely object-oriented language intended to support rapid construction of high-quality, extensible software. Cecil combines multi-methods with a simple classless object model, a kind of dynamic inheritance, modules, and optional static type checking. Instance variables in Cecil are accessed solely through messages, allowing instance variables to be replaced or overridden by methods and vice versa. Cecil’s predicate objects mechanism allows an object to be classified automatically based on its run-time (mutable) state. Cecil’s static type system distinguishes between subtyping and code inheritance, but Cecil enables these two graphs to be described with a single set of declarations, streamlining the common case where the two graphs are parallel. Cecil includes a fairly flexible form of parameterization, including explicitly parameterized objects, types, and methods, as well as implicitly parameterized methods related to the polymorphic functions commonly found in functional languages. By making type declarations optional, Cecil aims to allow mixing of and migration between exploratory and production programming styles. Cecil supports a module mechanism that enables independently-developed subsystems to be encapsulated, allowing them to be type-checked and reasoned about in isolation despite the presence of multi-methods and subclassing. Objects can be extended externally with additional