this report started working on denotational semantics in collaboration with Christopher Strachey. In order to fix some mathematical precision, he took over some definitions of recursion theorists such as Kleene, Nerode, Davis, and Platek and gave an approach to a simple type theory of higher-type functionals. It was only after giving an abstract characterization of the spaces obtained (through the construction of bases) that he realized that recursive definitions of types could be accommodated as well---and that the recursive definitions could incorporate function spaces as well. Though it was not the original intention to find semantics of the so-called untyped -calculus, such a semantics emerged along with many ways of interpreting a very large variety of languages. A large number of people have made essential contributions to the subsequent developments, and they have shown in particular that domain theory is not one monolithic theory, but that there are several different kinds of constructions giving classes of domains appropriate for different mixtures of constructs. The story is, in fact, far from finished even today. In this report we will only be able to touch on a few of the possibilities, but we give pointers to the literature. Also, we have attempted to explain the foundations in an elementary way---avoiding heavy prerequisites (such as category theory) but still maintaining some level of abstraction---with the hope that such an introduction will aid the reader in going further into the theory. The chapter is divided into seven sections. In the second section we introduce a simple class of ordered structures and discuss the idea of fixed points of continuous functions as meanings for recursive programs. In the third section we discuss computable functions and...

This paper proposes an extensional semantics-based formal specification of secure information-flow properties in sequential programs based on representing degrees of security by partial equivalence relations (pers). The specification clarifies and unifies a number of specific correctness arguments in the literature and connections to other forms of program analysis. The approach is inspired by (and in the deterministic case equivalent to) the use of partial equivalence relations in specifying binding-time analysis, and is thus able to specify security properties of higher-order functions and "partially confidential data". We also show how the per approach can handle nondeterminism for a first-order language, by using powerdomain semantics and show how probabilistic security properties can be formalised by using probabilistic powerdomain semantics. We illustrate the usefulness of the compositional nature of the security specifications by presenting a straightforward correctness proof for a simple type-based security analysis.

The Gelfond-Lifschitz operator [GL88] associated with a logic program (and likewise the operator associated with default theories by Reiter) exhibits oscillating behavior. In the case of logic programs, there is always at least one finite, non-empty collection of Herbrand interpretations around which the Gelfond-Lifschitz [GL88] operator "bounces around". The same phenomenon occurs with default logic when Reiter's operator \Gamma \Delta is considered. Based on this, a "stable class" semantics and "extension class" semantics was proposed in [BS90]. The main advantage of this semantics was that it was defined for all logic programs (and default theories), and that this definition was modelled using the standard operators existing in the literature such as Reiter's \Gamma \Delta operator. In this paper, our primary aim is to prove that there is a very interesting duality between stable class theory and the well founded semantics for logic programming. In the stable class semantics, class...

Much of relational algebra and the underlying principles of relational database design have a simple representation in the theory of domains that is traditionally used in the denotational semantics of programming languages. By investigating the possible orderings on powerdomains that are well-known in the study of nondeterminism and concurrency it is possible to show that many of the ideas in relational databases apply to structures that are much more general than relations. This also suggests a method of representing database objects as typed objects in programming languages. In this paper we show how operations such as natural join and projection -- which are fundamental to relational database design -- can be generalized, and we use this generalized framework to give characterizations of several relational database concepts including functional dependencies and universal relations. All of these have a simple-minded semantics in terms of the underlying domains, which can be thought ...

The design, implementation, and use of grammar formalisms for natural language have constituted a major branch of computational linguistics throughout its development. By viewing gramn, ar formalisms as just a special cause of computer languages, we can take advantage of the machinery of dcnoational semantics to provide a pre- cise specification of their meaning. Using Dana Scott's domain theory, we elucidate the nature of the feature systems used in augmented phrase-structure grammar formalisms, in particular those of recent versions of generalized phrase structure grammar, lexical functional grammar and PATRI1, and provide a dcnotational semantics for a simple gram- mar formalism. We find that the mathematical structures developed for this purpose contain an operation of feature generalization, not available in those grammar formalisms, that can be used to give a partial account of the effect of coordination on syntactic features.

A new definition of complex objects is introduced which provides a denotation for incomplete tuples as well as partially described sets. Set values are "sandwiched" between "complete" and "consistent" descriptions (representing the Smyth and Hoare powerdomains respectively), allowing the maximal values to be arbitrary subsets of maximal elements in the domain of the set. We also examine the use of rules in defining queries over such objects. 1 Introduction A characteristic of "complex-object" [1, 2] databases and "higher-order" relations [3, 4] is that the components of tuples are not restricted to taking only atomic values, but may be other tuples or even sets of tuples. A second property of complex objects and related information structures is that there is a natural ordering on the domain of values with an associated algebra [5, 6, 7]. For example, in Bancilhon and Khoshafian's ordering on tuples [1] [Name) 0 J.Doe 0 ] v [Name) 0 J.Doe 0 ;Age)21] This research was suppor...

We explore some foundational issues in the development of a theory of intensional semantics. A programming language may be given a variety of semantics, differing in the level of abstraction; one generally chooses the semantics at an abstraction level appropriate for reasoning about a particular kind of program property. Extensional semantics are typically appropriate for proving properties such as partial correctness, but an intensional semantics at a lower abstraction level is required in order to reason about computation strategy and thereby support reasoning about intensional aspects of behavior such as order of evaluation and efficiency. It is obviously desirable to be able to establish sensible relationships between two semantics for the same language, and we seek a general category-theoretic framework that permits this. Beginning with an "extensional" category, whose morphisms we can think of as functions of some kind, we model a notion of computation as a comonad with certain e...

The focus of this paper is nonmonotonic reasoning as it relates to logic programming. I discuss the pre-history of nonmonotonic reasoning starting from approximately 1958. I then review the research that has been accomplished in the areas of circumscription, default theory, modal theories and logic programming. The overview includes the major results developed including complexity results that are known about the various theories. I then provide a summary which includes an assessment of the field and what must be done to further research in nonmonotonic reasoning and logic programming. 1 Introduction Classical logic has played a major role in computer science. It has been an important tool both for the development of architecture and of software. Logicians have contended that reasoning, as performed by humans, is also amenable to analysis using classical logic. However, workers in the field of artificial 1 This paper is an updated version of an invited Banquet Address, First Interna...

The variety of power domain constructions proposed in the literature is put into a general algebraic framework. Power constructions are considered algebras on a higher level: for every ground domain, there is a power domain whose algebraic structure is specified by means of axioms concerning the algebraic properties of the basic operations empty set, union, singleton, and extension of functions. A host of derived operations is introduced and investigated algebraically. Every power construction is shown to be equipped with a characteristic semiring such that the resulting power domains become semiring modules. Power homomorphisms are introduced as a means to relate different power constructions. They also allow to define the notion of initial and final constructions for a fixed characteristic semiring. Such initial and final constructions are shown to exist for every semiring, and their basic properties are derived. Finally, the known power constructions are put into the general framewo...

this paper was published as Walicki, M.A. and Meldal, S., 1995, Nondeterministic Operators in Algebraic Frameworks, Tehnical Report No. CSL--TR--95--664, Stanford University