This paper discusses the use of link-sharing mechanisms in packet networks and presents algorithms for hierarchical link-sharing. Hierarchical link-sharing allows multiple agencies, protocol families, or traflic types to share the bandwidth on a tink in a controlled fashion. Link-sharing and real-time services both require resource management mechanisms at the gateway. Rather than requiring a gateway to implement separate mechanisms for link-sharing and real-time services, the approach in this paper is to view link-sharing and real-time service requirements as simultaneous, and in some respect complementary, constraints at a gateway that can be implemented with a unified set of mechanisms. White it is not possible to completely predict the requirements that might evolve in the Internet over the next decade, we argue that controlled link-sharing is an essential component that can provide gateways with the flexibility to

While today’s computer networks support only best-effort service, future packet-switching integrated-services networks will have to support real-time communication services that allow clients to transport information with performance guarantees expressed in terms of delay, delay jitter, throughput, and loss rate. An important issue in providing guaranteed performance service is the choice of the packet service discipline at switching nodes. In this paper, we survey several service disciplines that are proposed in the literature to provide per-connection end-to-end peqormance guarantees in packet-switching networks. We describe their mechanisms, their similarities and differences, and the performance guarantees they can provide. Various issues and tradeoffs in designing service disciplines for guaranteed performance service are discussed, and a general framework for studying and comparing these disciplines are presented. I.

this paper, we will assume that all window sizes are measured in units of maximum size packets, instead of bytes. In the original TCP specification [10], the window used by the sender, which we will denote by wnd, is the 1

The Internet has been a startling and dramatic success. However, multimedia applications, with their novel traffic characteristics and service requirements, pose an interesting challenge to the technical foundations of the Internet. In this paper we address some of the fundamental architectural design issues facing the future Internet. In particular, we discuss whether the Internet should adopt a new service model, how this service model should be invoked, and whether this service model should include admission control. These architectural issues are discussed in a nonrigorous manner, through the use of a utility function formulation and some simple models. While we do advocate some design choices over others, the main purpose here is to provide a framework for discussing the various architectural alternatives.

The need for supportingvariety of hard and soft real-time, as well as best effort applications in a multimedia computing environment requires an operating system framework that: (1) enables different schedulers to be employed for different application classes, and (2) provides protection between the various classes of applications. We argue that these objectives can be achieved by hierarchical partitioning of CPU bandwidth, in which an operating system partitions the CPU bandwidth among various application classes, and each application class, in turn, partitions its allocation (potentially using a different scheduling algorithm) among its sub-classes or applications. We present Start-time Fair Queuing (SFQ) algorithm, which enables such hierarchical partitioning. We have implemented a hierarchical scheduler in Solaris 2.4. We describe our implementation, and demonstrate its suitability for multimedia operating systems. 1

In this paper, we propose to use the idealized Hierarchical Generalized Processor Sharing (H-GPS) model to simultaneously support guaranteed real-time, rate-adaptive best-effort, and controlled link-sharing services. We design Hierarchical Packet Fair Queueing (H-PFQ) algorithms to approximate H-GPS by using one-level variable-rate PFQ servers as basic building blocks. By computing the system virtual time and per packet virtual start/finish times in unit of bits instead of seconds, most of the PFQ algorithms in the literature can be properly defined as variable-rate servers. We develop techniques to analyze delay and fairness properties of variable-rate and hierarchical PFQ servers. We demonstrate that in order to provide tight delay bounds with an H-PFQ server, it is essential for the one-level PFQ servers to have small Worst-case Fair Indices (WFI). We propose a new PFQ algorithm called WF 2 Q+ that is the first to have all the following three properties: (a) providing the tightest...

We present Start-time Fair Queuing (SFQ) algorithm that is computationally efficient, achieves fairness regardless of variation in a server capacity, and has the smallest fairness measure among all known fair scheduling algorithms. We analyze its throughput, single server delay, and end-to-end delay guarantee for variable rate Fluctuation Constrained (FC) and Exponentially Bounded Fluctuation (EBF) servers. We show that SFQ is better suited than Weighted Fair Queuing for integrated services networks and it is strictly better than Self Clocked Fair Queuing. To support heterogeneous services and multiple protocol families in integrated services networks, we present a hierarchical SFQ scheduler and derive its performance bounds. Our analysis demonstrates that SFQ is suitable for integrated services networks since it: (1) achieves low average as well as maximum delay for low-throughput applications (e.g., interactive audio, telnet, etc.); (2) provides fairness which is desirable for VBR video; (3) provides fairness, regardless of variation in server capacity, for throughput-intensive, flow-controlled data applications; (4) enables hierarchical link sharing which is desirable for managing heterogeneity; and (5) is computationally efficient.

This paper studies a simple strategy, proposed independently by Gallager [1] and Katevenis [2], for fairly allocating link capacity in a point-to-point packet network with virtual circuit routing. Each link offers its packet transmission slots to its user sessions by polling them in round-robin order. In addition, window flow control is used to prevent excessive packet queues at the network nodes. As the window size increases, the session throughput rates are shown to approach limits that are perfectly fair in the max-min sense. That is, the smallest session rate in the network is as large as possible and, subject to that constraint, the second-smallest session rate is as large as possible, etc. If each session has periodic input (perhaps with jitter) or has such heavy demand that packets are always waiting to enter the network, then a finite window size suffices to produce perfectly fair throughput rates. The round-robin method is considerably simpler than earlier strategies for achieving global fairness. The fair session rates are not explicitly computed, and the only overhead communication is that required for the window acknowledgments. The main drawback is that large windows are needed to achieve even approximately fair throughputs in some (hopefully rare) situations, and large windows permit large cross-network delays. Fortunately, the round-robin method offers other throughput guarantees that, while falling short of perfect fairness, do apply even for sessions with small windows. Such sessions are promised reasonable bounds on their cross-network packet delay as well.

this paper we present a class of scheduling algorithms --- called Rate-Proportional Servers (RPS) --- with bounds on end-to-end delays, buffer requirements and internal traffic burstiness equal to those of Weighted Fair Queueing. This class of algorithms is based on the notion of the potential

Integrated Services Packet Networks (ISPN) are designed to integrate the network service requirements of a wide variety of computer-based applications. Some of these services are delivered primarily through the packet scheduling algorithms used in the network switches. This paper addresses two questions related to these scheduling algorithms. The first question is: what scheduling services should an ISPN offer? In answer, we propose a scheduling service model for ISPN's which is based on our projections about future application and institutional service requirements. Our service model includes both a delay-related component designed to meet the ergonomic requirements of individual applications, and also a hierarchical link-sharing component designed to meet the economic needs of resource sharing between different entities. The second question we address is: what implications does this service model have for the packet scheduling algorithms? We answer this question by construc...