Results 1  10
of
12
Topological Incompleteness and Order Incompleteness of the Lambda Calculus
 ACM TRANSACTIONS ON COMPUTATIONAL LOGIC
, 2001
"... A model of the untyped lambda calculus induces a lambda theory, i.e., a congruence relation on λterms closed under ff and ficonversion. A semantics (= class of models) of the lambda calculus is incomplete if there exists a lambda theory which is not induced by any model in the semantics. In th ..."
Abstract

Cited by 27 (18 self)
 Add to MetaCart
A model of the untyped lambda calculus induces a lambda theory, i.e., a congruence relation on λterms closed under ff and ficonversion. A semantics (= class of models) of the lambda calculus is incomplete if there exists a lambda theory which is not induced by any model in the semantics. In this paper we introduce a new technique to prove the incompleteness of a wide range of lambda calculus semantics, including the strongly stable one, whose incompleteness had been conjectured by BastoneroGouy [6, 7] and by Berline [9]. The main results of the paper are a topological incompleteness theorem and an order incompleteness theorem. In the first one we show the incompleteness of the lambda calculus semantics given in terms of topological models whose topology satisfies a property of connectedness. In the second one we prove the incompleteness of the class of partially ordered models with finitely many connected components w.r.t. the Alexandroff topology. A further result of the paper is a proof of the completeness of the semantics of the lambda calculus given in terms of topological models whose topology is nontrivial and metrizable.
A Uniform Approach to Domain Theory in Realizability Models
 Mathematical Structures in Computer Science
, 1996
"... this paper we provide a uniform approach to modelling them in categories of modest sets. To do this, we identify appropriate structure for doing "domain theory" in such "realizability models". In Sections 2 and 3 we introduce PCAs and define the associated "realizability&quo ..."
Abstract

Cited by 21 (6 self)
 Add to MetaCart
this paper we provide a uniform approach to modelling them in categories of modest sets. To do this, we identify appropriate structure for doing "domain theory" in such "realizability models". In Sections 2 and 3 we introduce PCAs and define the associated "realizability" categories of assemblies and modest sets. Next, in Section 4, we prepare for our development of domain theory with an analysis of nontermination. Previous approaches have used (relatively complicated) categorical formulations of partial maps for this purpose. Instead, motivated by the idea that A provides a primitive programming language, we consider a simple notion of "diverging" computation within A itself. This leads to a theory of divergences from which a notion of (computable) partial function is derived together with a lift monad classifying partial functions. The next task is to isolate a subcategory of modest sets with sufficient structure for supporting analogues of the usual domaintheoretic constructions. First, we expect to be able to interpret the standard constructions of total type theory in this category, so it should inherit cartesianclosure, coproducts and the natural numbers from modest sets. Second, it should interact well with the notion of partiality, so it should be closed under application of the lift functor. Third, it should allow the recursive definition of partial functions. This is achieved by obtaining a fixpoint object in the category, as defined in (Crole and Pitts 1992). Finally, although there is in principle no definitive list of requirements on such a category, one would like it to support more complicated constructions such as those required to interpret polymorphic and recursive types. The central part of the paper (Sections 5, 6, 7 and 9) is devoted to establish...
Orderincompleteness and finite lambda models, extended abstract, in: LICS ’96
 Proceedings of the 11th Annual IEEE Symposium on Logic in Computer Science, IEEE Computer Society
, 1996
"... Many familiar models of the typefree lambda calculus are constructed by order theoretic methods. This paper provides some basic new facts about ordered models of the lambda calculus. We show that in any partially ordered model that is complete for the theory ofβ orβηconversion, the partial order is ..."
Abstract

Cited by 8 (1 self)
 Add to MetaCart
(Show Context)
Many familiar models of the typefree lambda calculus are constructed by order theoretic methods. This paper provides some basic new facts about ordered models of the lambda calculus. We show that in any partially ordered model that is complete for the theory ofβ orβηconversion, the partial order is trivial on term denotations. Equivalently, the open and closed term algebras of the typefree lambda calculus cannot be nontrivially partially ordered. Our second result is a syntactical characterization, in terms of socalled generalized Mal’cev operators, of those lambda theories which cannot be induced by any nontrivially partially ordered model. We also consider a notion of finite models for the typefree lambda calculus. We introduce partial syntactical lambda models, which are derived from Plotkin’s syntactical models of reduction, and we investigate how these models can be used as practical tools for giving finitary proofs of term inequalities. We give a 3element model as an example. 1
Towards Lambda Calculus OrderIncompleteness
 Workshop on Böhm theorem: applications to Computer Science Theory (BOTH 2001) Electronics Notes in Theoretical Computer Science
"... After Scott, mathematical models of the typefree lambda calculus are constructed by order theoretic methods and classified into semantics according to the nature of their representable functions. Selinger [47] asked if there is a lambda theory that is not induced by any nontrivially partially orde ..."
Abstract

Cited by 3 (3 self)
 Add to MetaCart
(Show Context)
After Scott, mathematical models of the typefree lambda calculus are constructed by order theoretic methods and classified into semantics according to the nature of their representable functions. Selinger [47] asked if there is a lambda theory that is not induced by any nontrivially partially ordered model (orderincompleteness problem). In terms of Alexandroff topology (the strongest topology whose specialization order is the order of the considered model) the problem of order incompleteness can be also characterized as follows: a lambda theory T is orderincomplete if, and only if, every partially ordered model of T is partitioned by the Alexandroff topology in an infinite number of connected components (= minimal upper and lower sets), each one containing exactly one element of the model. Towards an answer to the orderincompleteness problem, we give a topological proof of the following result: there exists a lambda theory whose partially ordered models are partitioned by the Alexandroff topology in an infinite number of connected components, each one containing at most one term denotation. This result implies the incompleteness of every semantics of lambda calculus given in terms of partially ordered models whose Alexandroff topology has a finite number of connected components (e.g. the Alexandroff topology of the models of the continuous, stable and strongly stable semantics is connected).
Functionality, polymorphism, and concurrency: a mathematical investigation of programming paradigms
, 1997
"... ..."
A Note on Absolutely Unorderable Combinatory Algebras
, 2001
"... Plotkin [18] has conjectured that there exists an absolutely unorderable combinatory algebra, i.e. an algebra which cannot be embedded in another algebra that admits a nontrivial compatible partial order. In this paper we prove that a wide class of combinatory algebras admits extensions with a non ..."
Abstract
 Add to MetaCart
(Show Context)
Plotkin [18] has conjectured that there exists an absolutely unorderable combinatory algebra, i.e. an algebra which cannot be embedded in another algebra that admits a nontrivial compatible partial order. In this paper we prove that a wide class of combinatory algebras admits extensions with a nontrivial compatible partial order.
Meaningless Sets in Infinitary Combinatory Logic
"... In this paper we study meaningless sets in infinitary combinatory logic. So far only a handful of meaningless sets were known. We show that there are uncountably many meaningless sets. As an application to the semantics of finite combinatory logics, we show that there exist uncountably many combinat ..."
Abstract
 Add to MetaCart
In this paper we study meaningless sets in infinitary combinatory logic. So far only a handful of meaningless sets were known. We show that there are uncountably many meaningless sets. As an application to the semantics of finite combinatory logics, we show that there exist uncountably many combinatory algebras that are not a lambda algebra. We also study ways of weakening the axioms of meaningless sets to get, not only sufficient, but also necessary conditions for having confluence and normalisation.