A classic problem from chemistry is used to test a conjecture that in domains for which data are most naturally represented by graphs, theories constructed with Inductive Logic Programming (ILP) will significantly outperform those using simpler feature-based methods. One area that has long been associated with graph-based or structural representation and reasoning is organic chemistry. In this field, we consider the problem of predicting the mutagenic activity of small molecules: a property that is related to carcinogenicity, and an important consideration in developing less hazardous drugs. By providing an ILP system with progressively more structural information concerning the molecules, we compare the predictive power of the logical theories constructed against benchmarks set by regression, neural, and tree-based methods. 1 Introduction Constructing theories to explain observations occupies much of the creative hours of scientists and engineers. Programs from the field of Inductiv...

Machine Learning algorithms are being increasingly used for knowledge discovery tasks. Approaches can be broadly divided by distinguishing discovery of procedural from that of declarative knowledge. Client requirements determine which of these is appropriate. This paper discusses an experimental application of machine learning in an area related to drug design. The bottleneck here is in finding appropriate constraints to reduce the large number of candidate molecules to be synthesisedand tested. Such constraints canbe viewed as declarative specifications of the structural elements necessary for high medicinal activity and low toxicity. The first-order representation used within Inductive Logic Programming (ILP) provides an appropriate description language for such constraints. Within this application area knowledge accreditation requires not only a demonstration of predictive accuracy but also, and crucially, a certification of novel insight into the structural chemistry. Thi...

Machine Learning algorithms are being increasingly used for knowledge discovery tasks. Approaches can be broadly divided by distinguishing discovery of procedural from that of declarative knowledge. Client requirements determine which of these is appropriate. This paper discusses an experimental application of machine learning in an area related to drug design. The bottleneck here is in finding appropriate constraints to reduce the large number of candidate molecules to be synthesised and tested. Such constraints can be viewed as declarative specifications of the structural elements necessary for high medicinal activity and low toxicity. The first-order representation used within Inductive Logic Programming (ILP) provides an appropriate description language for such constraints. Within this application area knowledge accreditation requires not only a demonstration of predictive accuracy but also, and crucially, a certification of novel insight into the structural chemistry. This paper describes an experiment in which the ILP system Progol was used to obtain structural constraints associated with mutagenicity of molecules. In doing so Progol found a new indicator of mutagenicity within a subset of previously published data. This subset was already known not to be amenable to statistical regression, though its complement was adequately explained by a linear model. According to the combined accuracy/explanation criterion provided in this paper, on both subsets comparative trials show that Progol's structurally-oriented hypotheses are preferable to those of other machine learning algorithms. ? The results in this paper are published separately in [7, 16] 1